Questions and Answers Part 3
Support the show: https://www.patreon.com/branham Available on Spotify, Google, and Apple Podcasts: https://william-branham.org/podcast Charles and John address the questions sent in by listeners to the show. We discu...
Support the show:
https://www.patreon.com/branham
Available on Spotify, Google, and Apple Podcasts:
https://william-branham.org/podcast
Charles and John address the questions sent in by listeners to the show. We discuss:
* Why Did You Expose William Branham as a Fraud?
* Are Prison Camps Being Built in Alaska?
* Where Did William Branham Learn His Seven Dimension Theology?
* Where Did William Branham Learn His Intelligent Serpent Doctrine?
* Explain William Branham’s Four Conflicting Commission Versions
* Explain Raymond Jackson's Dream
* Why Did Willard Collins Admit That People Knew the Issues With Branham's Ministry
* If William Branham Was Not the Prophet for our Age Then Who Is?
* Is the Message a Christian Religion?
Show transcript Hide transcript
Transcript
Hello and welcome to another episode of the William Brannum Historical Research Podcast. I'm your host, John Collins, the author and founder of William Brannum Historical Research at William-Brannum.org, and with me I have my co-host, researcher, minister, and friend Charles Paisley, the founder of christiangospelchurch.org. And together we're examining the history and the intersections in history between William Brannum and other key figures that either influenced or were influenced by the post-World War II healing revivals.
Charles, we're recording this straight through. We're splitting it up so people who were here last week, they see this as a separate episode, but my voice is getting incredibly worse if you can't already tell. And so I am an advertisement for the Ludens Wild Cherry cough drops. A friend of mine who was, he went to hollywood and he earned some limited fame as a movie star. He got me onto this, he showed me that you can take these things and it makes your voice last even longer. But we've gone so long at this point, my voice is getting almost gone.
But we want to answer the questions that people have sent in. We, again, we can't get to every question, but we, as you can tell, are trying very hard to get through the most important ones.
And this is our third episode in a series of questions and answers that we're giving. Those are good cough drops, John. Yeah, I really like that brand myself. So yeah, here we go into hour three of questions. We'll see if this hour fixes finishes up or not. We've got so many questions. I mean, we could go all day. But so the next question on the agenda is, why are you guys doing all this, John? Why are you making these podcasts? Why are you making these videos? Why are you exposing all these things about William Brown? And especially when you could
be exposing the Catholic. I said, I can't remember now if it was the first series of questions or the second that we got a slew of personal questions. We, often, what happens is people will, if they come in contact with something that makes them uncomfortable, one of the first questions that they ask is, what do you believe now? What church do you go to now? And it's always trying to shift the focus from the people away from the subject matter to my person.
And I just, I've learned over time, Charles. It's just, it's a game I don't play because it doesn't matter. You know, I could be, who knows what I could be? The biggest hypocrite in the world.
If the information and the research itself is 100% undeniably proving the facts that this was a false movement, which it was, it doesn't matter me. It doesn't matter my person. I could be whatever, you know, I could be Roman Catholic, which I'm not.
And interestingly, many of those people, they follow up with a second question, is the Catholic church paying for you? It's just, it's so fun. I mean, if people had any idea, the amount of time and energy I focus into trying to help people, they would never ask this question, but I did allow this one.
This is a personal, this is a question of personal attack, but I did allow this one because this is important to me. And I feel like it's something that we should address. Why are we doing this?
Why do I continue? I would rather be doing something else, Charles. I baseball or I like boating, I like fishing, I like my musical instrument. There's so many things that I would rather be doing than this, but if we don't do this, Charles, who else, it was in a position like you and me that could even do this, right?
There are people who left the message and, you know, I'm not discrediting any of that. There are people who left the message and they're actually more powerful in helping people out of the cult than anything that I do because their focus is to help people out of the cult.
My focus has never been that. My focus is to document what happened because I'm one of the few who knows the inside story. My family was at the top of this. I want to document what happened and I want it to be a beacon to the world that says there is danger in this water, do not swim.
You know, the majority of people who were in my position because I'm not the only one who was at the top of this. The majority left quietly and they let it go. They knew that if they were to be outspoken, they would get bullied, which we mentioned it in the finale episode, instantly I was bullied, instantly.
My uncle spread around the world almost, it was either the third day or second day that I'd left the message. As soon as he found out, I had an uncle that was very high ranking in this cult that spread that I was homosexual because homosexuality and...
this cult is a, it's a mark. You're marked and people won't listen to you. And it was highly effective. There were people that, you know, whether they believed it or not, I was marked. And none of it was true. But the family heavily pressured me. I also mentioned in the finale that after we started attending a new church, we men who were the henchmen of the cult used to come to that church every Sunday. And they would just watch us walk in the building. And it was harmless right. They're just watching us. But that was pressure. They were trying to intimidate us. That's
what it was. It was an intimidation strategy. So when people ask me, why do you do this? Well, the why is easy. I do it to document what I feel like I can document. And a lot of people can't because I know it. Why not attack the Catholic church? I don't know the Catholic church. I was never in it. The Catholic church, as you know, as research indicates, the Catholic church has a lot of skeletons in their closet. There are a lot of things that they have done that is not only questionable, but some of it is purely evil. But if you read through the archives of the Catholic
church, you're going to find where they have documented their own history. And to a large extent, the Catholic church is actually reformed. This cult erases their history. So for the Catholic church, I don't need to document it. You can go and Wikipedia and you can find the Catholic church and you can find its critical history. This cult, until I began my research, Charles, you know this as well as me because you researched, even on Wikipedia, everything was whitewashed initially.
There was not a single critical, there were some critical things, but there was not a single critical research of William Brannum and the healing revival is in the message that was prominent enough to gain attention. There was there was a lot out there, but it was all just kind of sliding through the cracks because there wasn't anybody who was in a position such as me, who was with the people at the top to know. So why do I do this? I do this because who else?
I think that's a good answer, John. And you know, for me, why I do it? I mean, I care about the people in the message. I love the people in the message. They're my people, right? I mean, and here I am, John, I'm over the halfway point of my life. I am setting my ways. I mean, I'm content with my lifestyle. I'm probably never going to change as far as any of that stuff goes.
You know, and I'm as far as the message lifestyle, I mean, I live the message lifestyle better than almost any other message. believe it I knew. A lot of them, a bunch of hypocrites, but I still live the message lifestyle better than a lot of them do. But you know, I love the people in the message and I want to help the people in the message. I left the message not because of any problems that I had along that way. I left the message when I found out they were lying to us about the midnight cry and the shout and the thunders and the seals opening. I found out that
I was all a hoax and they was lying to us about it. That is really what made me quit believing the message. And you know, when people like me and you, John, leave, right? I mean, I was content to go away very quietly. And that's what I did for over a year. I just left quietly.
And maybe all of you, a message leaders who are listening to this, you can take down some notes here. It might help you when other people leave. You know, if they just left me alone, I would win away quietly. That was entirely my plan, right? Because that's the trade, right? You let me go quietly. I'll go quietly. You don't let me go quietly.
I'm not going to be quiet. So I mean, if I have to live with, with, with months and years of harassment, well, God have mercy. I might as well just go ahead and start telling the truth about you people. And so that's exactly why I've done it. They haven't left me alone.
So you know, I'll just, I mean, what's the point? I feel like I have some obligation to tell the truth. And the only incentive not to is the fact that you might be able to live in peace without him harassing you constantly. But they're going to harass me constantly.
I might as well tell the truth about him. Right? And so that's, that's really my, it's a very simple logic in my head. So that's why I, that's part of why I did all this.
Because they, they want to, they're not going to let me live in peace. We'll find I might as well just tell the truth about him. So, so there's that aspect of it. And then I love those people. Those are my people. I'm, I, those are the people I want to help. And they already know how bad the Catholics are. I don't need to tell them about that. But, but they don't know about their own problems. So I'm telling them the things that they, they need to know. And if, and if they don't want to listen, that's okay. I, I still love them
anyway. And they're, they're fine people, some of them. But, but then the, the, but the ones who care, you know, that to check it out. Well, here it is. Here it is for you. So why am I doing this? I'm doing this because I love the people in the message. They are my friends.
They're my family. They're my only friends. They're my only family. So who else am I going to help if it's not the people that I care and love about? Right? I mean, so, so, so there you go. That, that'd be why I'm doing these things. Yeah. And you know, you mentioned that had they not bullied you. You probably would have went away silently. For me, this was a roller coaster. When I left this thing, it was an absolute roller coaster of ups and downs. And it's honestly, it was so traumatic for me. My memory has blocked a lot of it.
So it's real hard to remember every single hill and valley in the roller coaster. But I will. that I do share that, had they not bullied me, I probably would have just walked away.
I did disagree with some things, I had some questions and I, at its surface, for me, the biggest problem was he was just, he simply wasn't a prophet and they're claiming that he was, but prophets of God don't have failed prophecy and I had some questions about that.
Well, they tried to suppress it for me, they tried to not just suppress me, but they wanted to suppress this knowledge to the whole general cult and they, when they attacked me in the way that they did, it made me realize that something was wrong and that's what sparked it, sparked me into this research and digging.
I want to, I have to know what's wrong, I have to know, well, what are they hiding? I'm curious. If they're hiding something, why are they hiding it? So I had to dig deeper and it morphed over time, like you, I love the people in the cult.
I wish every single person in it could be free, especially the children, man, it, even today, it breaks my heart to see children growing up in this because there's a period of time where ignorance is bliss and as a child, you're happy and, you know, nothing seems, we're off or wrong, but suddenly, as you turn into adult, you can watch the people, even visually, I don't know if you've noticed this after leaving Charles, but you can see the rapid rate in which people appear to be getting older in the cult because they're so burdened down, it's just, it's wearing them out and it's, it breaks my heart.
So there was a period of time in which this happened and I'll go a bit deeper than I probably should, but also people tell me falsely that I'm this brave individual who has, you know, conquered, conquered mountains from being so brave and I can assure you it wasn't that.
I, as I was going through all of this, I've mentioned it in various different places in our podcast, but I was going through some severely traumatic issues and some really problematic health issues and I thought I was dying and so as I was, you know, leaving this cult and I was reconciling what had just happened to me, I thought, well, they're lying, the world needs to know, it needs to be documented in a way that in the future, after I die, anybody can find it and if I'm going to die, I'm just going to go out with a bang and then
I didn't die, you know, I don't know if it was because of, like I mentioned, people in the cult, they age a lot faster and more severely than people who were in normal Christianity that teaches the gospel.
After I left, things just suddenly started getting better and I don't... I don't know if it was just psychologically or there were some actual health issues that did get better. Medications that I was told I'd have to take the rest of my life that I don't take any longer.
After leaving the cult, it just simply got better. The pressure, the fear, the burden of fear that they place on you. It's kind of like this next question that we're about to get into.
The fear was a crippling fear. And there were things that were taught that just are so wrong and so weird and should not be even mentioned from a pulpit like this question. This person asked, didn't William Brannum say somewhere that the American government was building prison camps in Alaska to put message believers in?
Do you know if he said that and if he did, could you please add it to the list of topics that you could talk about? That's a really interesting statement of William Brannum there.
And yes, he did say on tape several times that people were going to be put into basically a concentration camp type gulag in Alaska if they did not submit to the World Council of Churches.
And this is something that he said at a number of times and the World Council of Churches was a boogie man that William Brannum used. Basically he set that up that that would be the image of the beast and then every denomination that joined the World Council of Churches was going to be worshiping the image of the beast, which is like taking the mark of the beast and you're going to burn up and go to hell basically.
So if you didn't submit to the World Council of Churches, you're going to then the alternative is they're going to send you to Alaska and put you in a gulag prison camp. And let me read you a quote of William Brannum to this effect.
This is from a 1962 sermon. He says he's telling a story here about someone that's going to end up in the gulag. He says the father stood up and said it's against our religious belief for our children to wear shorts, our little girl 16, 17 years old to wear shorts.
It's against our religious beliefs and they dismissed it and they expelled the child from school. And I understand that everybody that won't agree and come into the international agreement of this fellowship that they're trying to form to unite all the churches together, the Federation of Churches, that all that won't come in and unite with it, they'll make a little province.
They're going to send them to Alaska. You might as well get ready for cold weather because it sure looks like it's coming. So that's what William Brannum said about all the people who don't submit to the World Council of Churches going to Alaska.
You find other quotes like that, but honestly, John, that is just a nut-so-conspiracy theory. I don't believe the World Council of Churches ever really had a plan to... Exile all of the people who did not submit to them to a gulag in Alaska. I don't think that's true No, it's not and I've mentioned before I think in the last series, but we're getting into hopefully in the future we're getting into some interesting history American religious history about the invasion of the Communist scare and how it impacted the religion and through fundamentalism. They They basically took all of these different world conspiracy theories embedded it into American Christianity and then built entire
mountains of doctrine on top of it and at its core it was just simply false so William Brannum said this now If you go to a message cult church today, it's highly unlikely you're gonna hear it. I'm I'm certain that the person asking this is probably as old as me or older Because it's something that used to be taught they have whitewashed a lot of their history they To some extent they've tried to change it from an atmosphere of fear to a I don't know what you'd call it. It's not the gospel. It's an atmosphere of burden
That's that's how I call it. They change it from an atmosphere of fear to of hyper fear to an atmosphere of fear combined with burden. That's probably the easiest way to explain it and my family I have a family member who mentioned that every day as this person was getting ready to go to school they'll get on the bus and As they were walking to the bus with their parents they would turn and just grab onto the leg and cry and cry and cry I mean even to an age that it's Embarrassing to be like this
Because they were afraid that they would get on the bus and go to school When all of this would happen and that their parents would be sent to the prison camps while they were in school and they would never reunite with the parents That's the level of fear that our parents my parents grew up with That's you know the ear the generation of people that I'm talking about are the age of my parents So this is something that used to be widespread You're not going to hear it much in the cult today because they try to whitewash their history as we've mentioned
But this is problematic. This is a gospel of fear not a gospel of love Yeah, you know, it's it's crazy how How this stuff is evolved over the years and you're right the talk about world council of churches being the image of the beast is something that I Think gradually may have died out in a lot of places. I know in our churches. It was still mentioned occasionally But I want to say after the 90s, as you come into the early 2000s, it seems like, at least where I come from, it is an idea that's kind of faded away.
Even though I will say William Baranum included that in his interpretation of the fifth seal. So that is actually, thus say at the Lord from the angel that the World Council of Churches is the image of the beast.
So I don't think the message really can't completely divorce itself from that idea without actually rejecting the revelation of the seals. So yeah, at the end of the day it's just crazy conspiracy stuff.
I don't know, they would always say, and William Baranum said, too, that the World Council of Churches was a secretly communist institution, which I think there might actually be some truth to it that they were influenced by communism.
But ultimately with him that means communism was controlled by the Jews, and then it's all part of the deal with making a deal with Pope, everything else. All that is just bizarre nonsense. There's maybe elements of truth there that they grab that and then pile on with crazy conspiracy stuff, something else.
So moving on to the next question, John, it's where did William Baranum get the idea of seven dimensions from? Seven dimensions. You know, I've thought long and hard about this question, Charles, and how best to answer it.
I think William Baranum went deep into prophecy and envisioned the future and saw the Doctor Strange Marvel movie of the Marvel Multiverse. No, this is so weird and out there. I mean, to a normal Christian who's never heard this from behind a pulpit, they think, what?
And what on earth is this? This sounds like Eastern mysticism. And you know, my answer is simply that William Baranum had a lot of different influences, many of which were not Christian influences. And whenever you study this out to its conclusion, and especially if you study the heresies that Irenaeus mentioned, which ironically is one of William Baranum's quote unquote Church Age messengers, you find that this is woven throughout Eastern mysticism, to some extent, Jewish mysticism, Hinduism.
I think even they're various sects of mysticism that included this. This was not a Christian idea, but William Baranum, whatever his source that he ripped this from, whatever the source he tried to change it into a Christian doctrine, and then introduced it into the church as Christian theology when I can assure you, Charles, this is not Christian theology.
Right, there are certain things when William Baranum would talk about the seven dimensions that I do think give away its origins. When he talked about the Sixth Dimension, he would talk about the Sixth Dimension as being filled with cosmic light and the Sixth Dimension is where the Dead Saints live, basically the spirits of the Saints live in the Sixth Dimension, and then you would say the Seventh Dimension is where God lived.
And I think those two give us the strongest clue as to where this came from. And that is Hinduism. That is actually the beliefs of Hinduism. That the Sixth Dimension is where the cosmic light is, and that that's where the spirits of dead Saints or dead gurus to them live.
And then their gods live in the Seventh Dimension, the Hindu gods. So now did William Brown get that directly from Hinduism? I don't know if he did or not. So some of those ideas from Hinduism, Eastern mysticism, were imported into Quimbiism all the way back in the 1800s. So Phineas Quimbi incorporated some of those ideas, which then got picked up by Mary Baker Eddie, which also then got imported into, you know, mid and late century British israelism, right, which come into Christianity through that means. And so William Brown was in direct line succession from British israelite preachers who believe the same thing.
So did he get it directly from Hinduism or did he get it from Hinduism via Bosworth via Kenyan via Mary Baker Eddie via Phineas Quimbi? You know, it's hard to be sure just which one it is, but to be certain that is a Hindu idea. And let me, let me just read you a quote William Brown, I'm talking about that. He says, this is from a 1962 sermon, the count down, he says, now the sixth dimension is in Christ, the Saints, dead Saints or resting Saints, whose completely worked finished on earth and entered into rest with Christ under the altar beautifully.
If you would pair well at like a wonderful dream that you didn't want to wake up, it ain't a dream, it's natural, it's real, but just making a parable to you. And of course, the seventh dimension is God alone. So there's William Brown, I'm explaining, you know, what's in some of these dimensions.
And so let me also read to you a couple articles, this is from a Hindu guru. And John, I work with some Indian people who are Hindus and in leading up to this episode, I went and I asked him, like, hey, what do you believe about the sixth and seventh dimension? Well, they believe the same thing William Brown said about it.
Is what they believe about it. So I actually asked a Hindu about this before I recorded this episode in. Here's what a guru says off of a Hindu website, he says, the super conscious plane of the sixth dimension is situated at the third eye of Arna Chakra. Today, the Saints and the venerated sages have lived fully and consciously in this rarefied mind straight.
The beautiful, eccentric body of light caused me. quite a pure inner body exists in the sixth dimension. These, there were people who once lived in physical bodies and in the fourth dimension, who now live totally in the sixth dimension.
It is possible to live without a physical body in this dimension and still be fully conscious. So there's what Hindu Guru is saying about the sixth dimension. And then the seventh dimension, the same Guru says, the seventh dimension is a silent world.
It would be in be the heaven world of the gods, themselves, their retreat place. All of this takes place within you within the wonderful mind of man, your mind. So William Brannum's teachings on seven dimensions is modified Hinduism.
I would agree with that. I too, in the IT world, it's hard not to. I've worked with many Hindus and worked with many Christians who knew the gospel. And I have to say that a large number of people in the message live quite sheltered lives because if you're ever in an office environment where you have Hindus and you have actual Christians who actually know the gospel, it's really difficult to retain this false gospel religion because, for example, one of the Hindus I met and this is gonna sound funny, but this is actually true.
In Hinduism, you have a selection of gods. You can have as many gods as you want. You choose which gods. And there was this one Hindu I met that one of the gods he chose was Christ, which sounds odd, but that was his method of belief system.
And he believed, Krishna, or I can't remember the names of the different gods that he believed, but he also believed Christ. And I was like, so how does that work? Whenever the Bible says there's one true God, and he came up with this weird way to explain that basically says, yes, I believe in multiplicity of gods and also believe this, so I have cognitive dissonance.
That's essentially what he had. But it was interesting talking to him because he knew his Bible better than most message ministers that have preached that I've listened to. They'll say things that aren't just clearly not in the Bible and they'll say they are because they heard William Brannum say them and heard William Brannum say that it was in the Bible and they didn't look themselves.
And they've got one job, man. We're reading the Bible and preach it, but they're preaching William Brannum instead. So this Hindu knew more about Christ and the Bible and the gospel than these men, even though he's in a false version of Christianity because he believed in a multiplicity of gods, which was weird.
But then the Christians, they, the Christians that I've worked with, if you start talking about the halo and the lights. Immediately, they'll say, well, that's demonic. That's if you study spiritualism, if you study nosticism, if you study, and they're going to the different religions, those who are knowledgeable, and they will pick apart fully, everything without even talking theology, they will pick apart the religion just based on its premise.
And the first time I had that happen, I did not know how to answer because I'll be honest Charles there, but what they said was very correct. This is like witchcraft, man, this is sorcery, this is not Christianity.
And so I agree with you, I've talked to the Hindus, I know that that is likely where he got it. It's kind of common in eastern nesticism, so there could be different flavors of what he got, but what you found in, according to that guru, it's identical, almost down to the letter that it was Hinduism.
The next question, where did William Brannum get the doctrine that the serpent was a walking and talking animal but didn't have intelligence until he was taken over by the devil? How do we explain that this is a lie?
So I think what you will find is you can find the roots of that in the teachings of John Nelson Darby. So there was a writer named Charles McDonald, who sort of codified John Darby's teachings in the generation after John Darby, and he included that in his writings.
You'll find pieces of that found its way into the scofield Bible, for example, in the study notes of the scofield Bible, that the serpent was a creature that was basically taken over possession by Eve.
So those are ideas that influenced William Brannum. We know he had, I know for sure, he had both of those writings. That pictures of Charles McDonald's books in his library. We know he had a scofield study Bible.
So is that where he got it from most certainly is where he got the idea from? Yeah, this question for me is interesting because, and I could be wrong, I've not studied it as fully as I will in the future, but in white supremacy and Christian identity, they were trying to make this claim, and they were pointing to a pre-atomic race that existed.
And the ideology, and it differed from sect to sect, but the ideology was such that the serpent was a part of that race that wasn't the race of the good guys. And that's ultimately the white supremacist.
They ended up, this is where black people came from, ultimately. The Bible, if you read Genesis 3, it talks about the serpent being more crafty than any of the animals of the wild animals.
So the Bible clearly talks about, having intelligence before the fall. It also talks about the serpent talking. It's telling the woman we could eat or the fruit or the trees or the garden, but you must not eat the fruit.
It's in the middle of the garden. So parts of this question, just simply some of it came from the Bible, but the deeper question is that transition from the intelligence, I think, is where the heart of this question is because part of this is just straight from the Bible. But that transfer of intelligence, I do believe if I'm not mistaken, it came from white supremacy because even William Brannum, when he talks about when he first came in contact with the Christian identity doctrine at Roy Davis's church, he talks about how he was trying to say that he denied it initially,
but it was making that claim that there wasn't an intelligent being, and that's why the black people are, according to that white supremacy, very awful thing. That's why the black people are the way that they labeled them. But in my opinion, it probably came from white supremacy.
Yeah, John, while you was speaking, I went and I just pulled the book off of my shelf. This is, this is a copy of what's in William Brannum's library. This is a commentary on Genesis. And I said, it was Charles Macdonald. I'm sorry, it was actually Charles McIntosh. This is basically a codification or a commentary of the teachings of the brethren, Darby's teachings that was produced after Darby died. And yeah, in here, he basically spells out roughly what we would have believed about that sort of thing, you know, and you're correct, John, in saying that these actual ideas
of pre-Adamites come from white supremacists, absolutely. So they were trying to find ways to justify slavery, and they proposed the idea that there was a race of soulless animals that looked more or less like people who God made as animals to be servants to Adam. And naturally, they said that was the pro-generators of the non-white races. And yes, then so it's basically just piggybacking on those ideas that say Satan possessed one of those creatures and then seduced Eve.
And as far as how do we know that that's wrong? Well, I mean, do you believe that God created a race of sentient animals that could talk and speak, and we're in every way just about like humans, but they didn't have souls who were intended to be slaves. Yeah, I don't think so. I don't think so.
So I don't believe God would do a thing like that. And so now if you do, well, that's between you and God, but I just don't believe that God created a race of sentient feeling animals.
So they're just about like people, but we're intended to be slaves to the master race for all eternity. I just don't believe. I don't believe in that. Can you explain about the four versions of William Brannum's Angelic Commission story again?
I would like to know more about the second version where he was in his living room. How do you know that there is that second version? And I believe this question came from someone who was trying to understand back when we did the angel came to me.
We said there were four versions of the angelic commission, the 1945 version, the in my room version, the in a cave cabin version, and then the in a cave version. So you got the four versions.
And they were wanting to understand why we thought the in my room version was different from the cave or the cabin. Yeah. You can tell this also is from somebody who was in the cult.
We mentioned this in one of the previous questions. But if you have a person who makes a false claim and you suddenly realize its faults, if you're not brainwashed and manipulated, you're just going to leave and ignore every single thing that the person has said forever because they just lied to you.
But if you're in the cult and they make a false claim and you learn its false, and then they've got another claim, well, you mind immediately tries to say, well, let's ignore the false one.
He made this other claim and it was true. And then you'll defend that claim until somebody can prove its false. And then you say, well, no, he's got this other claim. Well, it's true.
And that's the way brainwashed individuals think. It's sad, but that's that's the way that they think. It's I've been trying to think how best to talk about this. The simple answer is we got it from his recordings.
He talks about it himself on the transcripts. You can go back to one of our previous podcast episodes and you can we actually on the video feed, we actually show the text of it so you can see where he got it.
But the problem, like I said, I'm addressing a different question than the one was asked because this is coming from a person who's probably going through that, trying to reconcile how they've been lied to.
So Charles, if you were to commission me to build you a shelf for your living room and I come home and I tell my wife, I've been commissioned to build a shelf and I go to my garage and I start building it.
And then you call me again and you say, John, I'm commissioning you to build me a shelf for my living room. And I say, okay, I'm in the garage, I'm building it, Charles, I'll build you the shelf.
You call me again, 10 minutes later, John, I am commissioning you to build a shelf for my living room. I'm going to finally, I'm going to start saying, Charles, look man, I'm in the garage, I've got the wood.
on the saw. I'm cutting it. Let me build it. You'll be fine. And then you call me back 10 minutes later. John, I'm commissioning you to build a shelf for the living room. Well, that's what happens with William Brannum. If you just go to table.brannum.org, which is the cult headquarters transcripts, just type in the word commission. And you're going to see, I commission you to heal the sick.
I commission you again to heal the sick. I commission you another time to heal the sick. I commission you another, another, another, another time. One of the best books that lays this out. His Peter Dyser's legend of the fall. He's the first time I ever actually never noticed it until he pointed it out. He's commissioned left and right. Here's a commission. Here's another commission. You get a commission. You get a commission too. It reminds me of Oprah. You get a car. You get a car.
Even in somebody sent me one of the earliest pamphlets that William Brannum, I think this is a 1945 pamphlet. William Brannum is commissioned to heal the sick without even an angel. So in this pamphlet, he talks about he is commissioned two times in the same pamphlet to heal the sick. One time, I think it's 1936. If I'm looking at the dates correctly in this book, 1936 was the earliest.
Then again, 1945. And then if you look, they don't talk about this one in the cult. But if you look at the transcripts, there's another one, another one, there's angels, there's demons, there's all kinds of weird commissions. But the simple answer is if you're looking for it, go to the transcripts, type in commission. Yeah. If you want to check out Peter Dyser's book, it is really good.
And you're right, John. I mean, there he documents the dozen different times, William Brannum. I think more than a dozen times that William Brannum claimed that he was commissioned. And yeah, it is kind of bizarre. How many times does a man need to be commissioned? It's a lot, right? It is odd. And I understand the question to about the four different versions because the 1945 version, that's very clearly wrote in, you know, I was not disobedient to the heavenly vision.
The cabin version is very clearly documented like in his book, Manson from God. And then the K version is William Brannum extensively told that on tape. So all three of those versions are very clear. And I think when we did the episode on this, we mentioned that this second version was the most obscure one just because there's the least on it. But the reason that we would suggest to you that it is a separate version is because there are details in that which cannot fit with either a cabin or a cave and also don't fit with the 1945 version. And he also doesn't say he's in a cabin
or a cave in that version. He says it just I'm in my room. Let me just read you one quote. from from one of the times he told this version and these are the very first times he told this on tape is this version I'll just kind of point out a detail to you here he says in Assermin the Angel of God from 1947 he says a little over two years ago so notice that put it in 1945 right a little over two years ago which is when the I was not disobedient to the heavenly vision track
came out a little over two years ago I was sitting in the room right I was reading the little scofield Bible and I heard something you know he just says I was sitting in the room he doesn't tell you where he's at other than he's sitting in a room but he says I heard something first I saw a light and I thought it was an automobile that turned the corner but it was not but it turned but it got brighter and I looked out the door and there was no automobile okay now if William Brandon was in a cave if do you think he'd be opening a door to go
let's see if an automobile turn the corner no okay so he don't fit the cave one and if you if you put it for example with the cabin one the cabin story he's out in the middle of the wilderness and he had to hike back there to get there there's no street for a car to be turned in a corner right so the details of these stories do not fit with cabin or cave right and it's this is like the hybrid where he's going from the 1945 version because he's putting this in 1945 is the hybrid between that and the transition to the cabin version and if
you the reason we would suggest you this is his home on Ewing Lane is because if you know where his home on Ewing Lane is it's right at a street corner where if a car turned the corner the light would shine right through the windows in his home on Ewing Lane so it really the internal evidence in the story would suggest to us that he is in his room or in his home on Ewing Lane and a street turn car turns the corner and shine to light through his window and so this is what he thought it was so I just hope you catch that so that that
is why we would say that second version is a distinct version that's neither cabin nor cave nor 1945 and at the end of the day John you know if you don't want to you know if you want to merge that in with the cabin version I mean I think that's that's reasonable if you wanted to do that but you still got three versions of the story and and you still got an angel that told him things that are not true and misquoted the Bible and told him a false prophecy so you no matter what you do with that detail the story fails on other
points and I would not hang the angelic commission being false simply on on this one little detail of the second version I would hang the it being false on just the whole broad scope right you've got all of these different versions and you've got an angel misquoting the Bible and an angel telling him he's gonna go do things that he never actually did right And then you've got these really dramatic changing versions over time.
So for me, it's just a really huge big red flag that there is something seriously wrong with the angelic commission story. For me, it's this simple. If somebody told you that it was a matter of life or death that you go out to this road and turn right and go past a cave, and then you confirm it with them and you say, okay, so I'm going out to the road and I'm turning right and I'm going out past the cave.
And he says, no, I want you to go out and I want you to turn left and go by a cabin. And then you say, well, I just want to confirm this because you told me just a second I go turn right and you ask him a third time and they say, no, it's a matter of life or death that you come into my living room.
Well, at some point you have to believe that this is not a matter of life or death because this person clearly has a problem and you would ignore everything that he said. But if your brain washed in this cold Charles, you believe it is a matter of life or death and you believe all of these things.
So you're literally going to go left, right, living room, wherever you want to go. And it's like so many things in the message. There are so many things that if you take the one thing that he said and then take another thing that he said and try to mix them together, the details just can't go together.
And so they're completely false. Just one more point, John, on this, which is a point I think we've probably made before. But, you know, if you take the original 1945 version and that I was not disobedient, he gets his commission, he goes and he heals Reverend Ordie's daughter.
You take the in my room version for that he tells in 1947 the angel comes to him in 1945 in that version and then he goes to St. Louis, he heals Reverend Ordie's daughter.
When you come to the cabin version, Mike and a man sent from God, the angel comes to him in 1946 in this version and then he goes to St. Louis and heals Reverend Ordie's daughter.
Or you go to the cave version, right, which is supposed to happen either 47 or 48 depending on the version, the angel comes to him in the cave and then he goes to St. Louis and heals the Reverend Ordie's daughter, the detail that is consistent across all the versions and he don't always tell the story end to end, but when you get each version end to end, he always goes to the end to St. Louis and he heals Reverend Ordie's daughter.
Well, we know that actually did happen in 1945. She was healed of St. Vitus Dance, which is a non-chronic condition which people generally spontaneously recover from anyway. He went and he was healed of St. Vitus Dance in 1945 according to all the evidence, right?
The newspaper articles, the testimony of her father and other family that we've talked to as well. So he went there in 1945 and so that is ultimately the piece that points you back that that 1945 and I was not disobedient is the one closest to the truth because that is what actually did happen in 1945.
Right, and I will mention that in this there is no angel. In this commission there is no angel. So the angel was introduced after this publication was printed. So the next question, and this is a question for you, Charles, I won't even attempt to answer it.
You said that Raymond Jackson never had the pyramid dream, but he did have a dream. Can you explain that? Sure, so Raymond Jackson did have dreams. He had lots of dreams. Dreams featured very prominently in his ministry.
And there's a number of dreams that he did tell to William Brannum. Now, what's important here is to just to notice what William Brannum does with it. So Raymond Jackson in this particular pyramid dream, I say that in ear quotes, pyramid dream, he dreamed that he saw William Brannum with like a crowbar and he's like prying up a kind of a cavity in a rock and as he prized up the cavity inside this cavity and the rock is all these gems and jewels and everybody oozes and awes and then William Brannum walks away and after William Brannum kind of disappears over the horizon,
all the people go crazy. Where did William Brannum go? And so that's the gist of the dream and it kind of ends with everybody going crazy looking for William Brannum. But there is no pyramids.
There is no symbolism in that at all that connected with what William Brannum tried to do with it. Now, what happened is when William Brannum preached the seven seals, he says, now I told you that the angels came to me in the constellation formation, right?
In the shape of a pyramid and then he goes and he connects that to William Brannum and Jackson's dream and he says, just like junior Jackson's dream, right? They came to me in the shape of the pyramid and he was using that dream to try and say that this supernatural experience where the angels came to him in a shape of a pyramid is vindicated.
But what happens is there's no angels in Raymond Jackson's dream. There's no pyramids. There's no constellations. There is nothing in Raymond Jackson's dream that he actually did have that matches the symbolism that William Brannum is drawing on.
William Brannum totally made up the pyramid dream. There was no pyramid dream. In fact, there was no dream that Raymond Jackson had that matched the symbolism of William Brannum at all, right? William Brannum just totally fabricated the pyramid dream and attributed to Raymond Jackson.
And Raymond Jackson is even on tape saying, I never had the pyramid dream. He had another dream about these gems and a cavity. And when you see that, you realize there's no matches in the symbolism here.
It's just, you know, It just ceases to make sense. And then you have William Brannum making up these really crazy stories. And that's not the only dream of Raymond Jackson that William Brannum fabricated, fabricated, and made up, and then said he had it.
And Raymond Jackson covered that lie for him for years and years and years and decades till about 2002, Raymond Jackson in Assurman did tell us the truth about how William Brannum had fabricated his dreams.
All right, John, we've got one more question here. Question is, why did Willard Collins say people have known these things for years? I've mentioned that a few times. In fact, I think it's in either two or three of my books.
There was a point of time in which we talked about it in one of the previous questions in which I fully would have just walked away silently. I didn't care. These people can believe what they want, right?
And then as you know, the bullying starts and all of the different pressuring, the intimidation strategies. Well, there was a period of time that was very traumatic for me in which I suddenly realized that not a single person that I respected was trustworthy, but more to the point, they had all turned on me.
My own grandfather, I respected my grandfather up until when was it? It was first or second week of January, 2012.
He was probably the man that I looked up to the most. He was the head pastor of the Brannum Tabernacle had been for 50 years, I think it was, but the moment in which I mentioned that I had a question and even just, I had not even fully discounted William Brannum as a prophet.
I just knew that he had some failed prophecies and I was twisted and manipulated to believe that you could be a prophet and also I failed prophecies, which is a problem. But there came a point of time in which they were trying to bully me.
And Grandpa was going to send some henchmen to my house. I won't go into too many details, I'll just leave it like that. They were going to send some people out to my house and he threatened me over the phone and that was the point in which I said, look Grandpa, I don't know why you're about to threaten me and I probably said some things that I shouldn't have, but I was a little bit angry and upset because all of this was happening and I had no idea why it was happening.
But I said, look, this thing, there's something wrong here and I mentioned, I had been studying the 1933, quote unquote, been prophecies of 33, and I was suddenly starting to realize that there weren't just seven.
There were more. And there were more because whenever one was proven to be a failure, it would shift into a different one. And I was trying to explain to him that something's wrong here.
The ministers are saying things that aren't true. And I mentioned specifically to Grandpa, there are people, especially in this town, that worshipping William Brannum as a God. And I said, how can this thing even be of God if this prophecy that I'm looking at, and I think the one that I was specifically talking to that initiated the conversation was the female president prophecy of saying, William Brannum said that it was fulfilled multiple times with the election of Kennedy, and as a grandpa, Kennedy's not even female.
So he had to change it, and I said, for me, if you can change it that drastically, that it can change from male to a female, that is the polar opposite. You can literally change any prophecy to mean anything that you want, and say that you had a prophecy that's true.
And I said, have you known this? And Grandpa said, people have known this for years. What does it hurt for you to believe it anyway? In other words, I would like for you to be silent.
I would like for you to leave silently. And the irony in that, Charles, is that's really all I wanted to do, man, I wanted to leave silently. But whenever they started coming down on me like this, it wasn't just Grandpa.
I had multiple family members of rank and authority in the message from multiple states that began bullying me and my family. And they cut my wife and children off from the cult, had no idea whether my wife even believed it or not.
They just said that she is doomed to hell like I was, and I knew something was wrong. So the reason why he said this was, this was part of the bullying strategy. They were literally going to send men out to my house, and I had to take some precautions.
I won't go into details. I'll just leave it at that. But this was very, very problematic. The way they react to questions, I mean, if, especially critical questions, if that does not demonstrate that this thing is a cult, I mean, I mean, it's something else, right?
I mean, you, if the question seems to like hit critically at the core of their beliefs, they kind of lose it. And I think, John, to me, that actually speaks to the weakness of their own faith and their beliefs, right?
They know it's weak, and they don't want to be questioned on it. And a lot of them know better, especially... the ones up at the top that have been around a long time, they know that they know there's very serious problems and they have the best of weak belief in the message to begin with.
As I've said before, a lot of people in leadership in the message do not actually believe the message. They know this, they know this isn't true and just like you found out, they already knew the problems right before we even asked about them and they just want to try and bowl you over and shut you up, right? And it is really absolutely despicable. You know, I have like some of the people the same thing that have come down hard on me are like one of the men I asked him. So William Brennan made all the stuff up about the cloud. He says,
yeah, that's pretty much how it is. Boy, he came down on me like a ton of bricks for not believing the mess. He didn't even believe it. He's the one who told me one true.
You know, the same with the KKK stuff. It was the preacher who told me one of the preachers who told me the KKK stuff was true. Come down on me like a ton of bricks that it ain't true.
He's one who told me it's true, right? And I can go on and on, right? I've, John, you're not the one who convinced me that this stuff is true. They did when they told it to me from their own lips because they knew it was true before we even started looking into it. And they thought they would just bowl me over and I would, oh, okay, you all believe that that this is all true and we're just all going to go along anyway. I don't think so. I mean, I have a conscience. I want to sleep at night and I don't want to go to hell for
a line of people for 50 years. And if you guys are comfortable with that, why, hey, go ahead with that. But I mean, I know what the Bible says about liars and the like of fire.
I don't want to be in there. Sounds uncomfortable. But anyway, let's go to the next question. I think the most common question we get of all, whenever I look through the comment feeds and people send it into my email is this, if William Brannum was not the prophet for age, then who is? So John, this is a question that gets into, we might say theology or the Bible a bit. So I'm going to be careful in how I answer this question here. But I would suggest you know, the premise of that question is itself flawed. All right. So you, you're,
that, that, that question is where do we go from here? If William Brannum wasn't the prophet for the age who is, that tells me you're looking for a new cult leader. That's, that question tells me you're looking for someone to replace William Brannum as your cult leader. Not a good idea. Not a good idea. Okay. So you need to just step back and ask, why are you even asking that question? Why do you think there is such a thing as a prophet to this age? Who told you there's such a thing as a prophet to this age, right? Was it
by chance the man who thought he was the prophet to this age, right? I mean, you got to examine, why do you even believe in that? And I would suggest to you, if you're in the message, the only reason you believe there's a prophet to this age is because the man claiming to be the prophet to this age told you there was the only reason you believe there is a.
church age messenger is because the man claiming to be the seventh church age messenger told you there was such a thing, right? You don't believe these things because you opened up the Bible and read them out of the Bible. You believe these things because the man claiming to be all these things told you there was such a thing to begin with, right? And before you decide to go out and look for someone to fill William Brannem's shoes as your next cult leader, I would suggest you you might want to go back and actually re-examine and be sure that you should even believe in such a thing as that
to begin with, right? And until you're willing to do that, I certainly would not. In any way, shape or form, be pointing to you towards a new prophet for you to follow. And that would be my most immediate advice on this question. The first time I had this question, somebody asked it and you know, this is usually coming from a person who's in the cult and what they're trying to say is just like you said, if we're not following this cult leader, then tell me who is the correct cult leader to follow. Generally, they follow this up with, you're working with the Catholic church.
The Pope is your prophet for the age. And they're like you said, it's flawed, but there are a few flaws here. There are people who have left the cult, who are in our support groups. And there, I've actually heard recordings of this. Their ministers will say you're following Charles or you're following John as the new prophet. Well, we've never had a prophecy, Charles.
So we can't be a prophet, but even deeper than that, prophet for the age. I'll never will forget the first person that asked this. I said, well, are you certain that there are church ages? And they said, absolutely, it's in the book of Revelation. I said, well, show me the verse for that. And they go look and all they find are seven churches. They don't find seven church ages. And they said, something's wrong. I know that this says age in here. I said, well, show me where? And they look and they look and end it up. You know,
it's obviously not there because that is extra biblical. It's the dispensationalist theology. So what ended up with is they began to attack my person because they can't defend what they believe. They resort to attacking the person. And that's the point in which I just cut it off because I won't once it gets to that level, I don't engage because I can't help them. But like you said, the premises faults, it is looking for another cult leader. But generally, it's usually a weapon to attack. So when you see that in the comment feeds, it's because they want to say that we're following the Catholic church or
in the words of some of the comment, the people who were commenting, they say, John is paid by the Pope. And that's I wish I was paid by the Pope. I don't wish that I would follow the Pope's agenda, but I'd love to have some money, but we don't get any money from the Pope.
I'll tack on one more thing, because the first part of that question was where do we go from here?
I would say this, if you want to continue to be a Christian, where you go from here is Jesus Christ. I mean, that really is the answer. Don't go find a new cult leader, go find Jesus for goodness' sake.
I mean, that's the answer, and that's the problem that got you in this pickle to begin with, is because you let somebody usurp the role of Savior in your life. Instead of dependent on Jesus to save you, you're dependent on William Brownham Shout to save you, or you're dependent on William Brown's message to save you, or this side or the other from the message to save you, rather than dependent on, I don't know, what a novel idea.
Let's depend on the Savior to actually save us, right? I mean, Christianity 101, how about go back to the basics and start believing in the Savior is actually going to save you, and then go from there.
That would be my most important instruction. That is what I have tried my best to do. Now, I am most formerly a cult preacher, so, hey, maybe I'm crazy. So, you don't even just take it because I said it.
But that would be my suggestion to you is, go get the basics of the gospel right, and start, go back and actually believe the Savior saves you, and then go from there. So, that brings us to our last question, John, that we have, that we're going to try and fit in today.
There's so many more questions, John. We're already over, I think, three hours of reporting questions. So, the question is how far do we want to go with this? I think we're going to maybe cap it off here.
But hey, if you guys got more questions and want to send them in, go ahead. Maybe one day we'll do another Q and A episode. But here's the final question. Is the message a Christian religion?
Wow, that's a tough one to answer, Charles. My response for this would be, what is the message?
In your sect, Charles, if I ask you, what is the message? You're going to give me a different answer than, in the main sect, what is the message? I can assure you if I go to the West Coast and I ask a church, what is the message?
They're going to give me a different answer as to the East Coast, what is the message? There are no two churches, sometimes even within the same city who have the same views on what was the quote unquote message.
I've actually heard ministers say the message is that Christ is returning and God has called the people. Well, that's a Christian notion, man, if that's the Christian, if that's the message, that's the Christian message.
I've also heard some say that God has called a prophet to condemn the world to hell and to condemn the Christian. who did not accept the prophet as their ticket to heaven. You know, they use other verbiage as their ticket to heaven.
God sent this message to condemn those to hell. Well, that's the anti-Christian message. So if you asked, is it a Christian religion? Well, what's the religion? Is my second question? First, what's the message?
But second, well, what's the religion? It's different. You don't find any agreement or coherent thought. And I always go back to the verse. God is not the author of confusion. When you examine the religion, it is a religion of confusion.
When you examine any doctrine and you go study, we've got the resources to study what the man said. Was he a trinitarian? He said, I accept the holy trinity. He accepts specifically, I accept the third person in the trinity.
So any group who forms off of William Brannum's theology of accepting the third person of the trinity is going to oppose those who say, anybody who accepts the persons of the trinity are condemned to hell.
They've chosen the mark of the beast. Well, that's their message. That's their religion. William Brannum said both. So which is it? Is he a trinitarian? Is he anti-trinitarian? What is the message? What is Christianity?
The problem for me is that this is deeper than just the message. This, we mentioned this, I think, in the first series of questions that we answered, but this was a plague that infected the Christian church.
And it was a movement that transformed what it meant to be Christian into a general public audience. Many of those men who left this knowing that it was heresy, they got into positions and they were influenced.
So they began to influence denominations. So this was a cancer that spread throughout American Christianity. It changed the view of what is the church. The church is the people. If you read the Bible, the church is the people.
But in the message, they think the church is the message people or the message, denomination of faith, but they'll say we're not a denomination. Everybody's welcome, but everybody's not welcome. So for me, the answer is this simple.
If you are in a movement that believes simply the Christian gospel and you follow the words of Christ and you don't put any power in a human being as your mediator between God and man, then you're in a Christian religion.
Can you say that about any message sect? I haven't seen one. Now they may exist. I haven't seen one. that's like this, almost everyone that I've been to, you have to accept William Brannum in one shape or one way shape or form as your mediator between God and man.
Yeah, so is the message of Christian religion? I mean, it is a loaded question, like you said, John, and it is because that is so hard to answer because even within the same sect, two churches will define the message differently. And you have on one end of the spectrum, message churches that are not very different than vanilla penicostalism. And I believe that penicostals in general are Christians, right? So I would say that on that end of the spectrum, sure, the message believers are Christians. Then you get to the other end of the spectrum where they baptize and pray in the name of William Brannum. And no, they are not Christians, right?
There's definitely full in idolatry on a false God. And so you have the spectrum from one end to the other. And at a certain point in that spectrum, you cross the line where William Brannum is usurping of the role of savior, the role of Holy Spirit, the role of God. And at a certain point, you go so far down that line and you've got to say, I don't think these guys are Christians anymore, right? When William Brannum has entered your formula for salvation, no, you're not Christians anymore, right? When the Holy Spirit is no longer guiding your life, but something else,
the message preacher has entirely usurped the role of Holy Spirit guiding your life, are you Christian anymore? I don't know. Maybe you think start to get fuzzy, right?
Is some of our people in the message Christians short? Lots and lots of people in the message are true genuine Christians. And then also lots and lots of people in the message are idolaters of the worst sort and actually worship the false God. And I would not want to paint any paint with too broad of a brush. I think that generally it's not up to you and I to judge people's hearts and souls as individuals. That's up to God, right? But we can say the message leans towards an idolization of William Brannum. Even the sex that would not present themselves in
that way, there is some role that belongs to God that they had definitely given over to William Brannum or to their present leadership slash ministry standing in the role of God. That is depending on which group it is, is how problematic it is. So is it a Christian religion?
It depends. It depends. So I think that is the last question. We're going to try and tackle here, John. It's been great answering everybody's questions. I feel like we've got to the most pressing ones that I've been collecting these for a while.
Some of these come from just all over the world. Some of these questions from our different friends and listeners and so it's been really great interacting with the audience. So like I said before, if you've got any more, go ahead, send them in.
Maybe we'll do another QA episode or maybe nothing else. Maybe point you to places where we've answered the questions before. What Charles, this has been quite an adventure. Start to finish from episode one to, I think I said it wrong in our finale.
I think I said 160 something, but I think it's 60 something that we've done. It feels like 160 something, but it's been quite an adventure in this episode has been, if you know my voice, I get really hoarse.
So this is quite an adventure. And I am a poster child for Lutin's cough drops because you talk too much and we will help you talk more. That's, it's gotten me through the episode.
I did not think I would have a voice when we got done. We're at, what is it? Three and a half, almost four hours, we've recorded. But this is, as we mentioned in the finale, this is the final after finale episode of Q&A that we did promise you and we're taking a break.
These episodes, we're going to split them up and they'll go out for a few weeks. But Charles and I are gonna be taking some much needed R&R. And I hope Charles comes back.
I would love it if everybody would write into Charles and tell him how much you enjoyed Charles on this episode that we've done for this 60-something series on William Brannum. I'm getting really excited about the stuff that is upcoming and I'm trying to talk him from my side as well because I want to get into the sinister history that is even darker than William Brannum that was the foundation that William Brannum built his ministry upon.
Once we discovered this, I started digging in it. I'm aching for more. I want to know why. I want to know how. How did these men do this? Why did they cover it up?
So please write into Charles. Tell him you enjoyed the work on the podcast. You can write him at ChristianGospelChurch.org on the contact page. If you want to write in to thank me, it's William-Brannum.org.
Write me on the contact page and we would love to hear from you. Send us your questions if you have more. Hopefully we'll get a chance to do another Q&A. But as for now, we are signing off and we're taking a much-needed vacation from it.