Podcast Episode

Manifested Sons of God: The Dangerous Evolution of a Misunderstanding

John and Chino examine the "manifestation of the sons of God" teaching built around Romans 8 and trace how the idea developed through Latter Rain, William Branham, Hobart Freeman, George Warnock, and later charismatic...

2026, November 3 01:01:44 17 tags

John and Chino examine the "manifestation of the sons of God" teaching built around Romans 8 and trace how the idea developed through Latter Rain, William Branham, Hobart Freeman, George Warnock, and later charismatic movements. They compare the language of Romans 8 with interpretations that turned the passage into an expectation of a special end-times ministry of matured sons.

They also discuss the distinction some teachers made between "children" and "sons" of God, the use of Greek terminology, divine healing teachings, the Feast of Tabernacles interpretation, and the way successive layers of doctrine were connected with authority, hierarchy, and dominion. The discussion emphasizes reading biblical passages in context and recognizing when later interpretations add concepts not stated in the text.

______________________
Weaponized Religion: From Christian Identity to the NAR:
Paperback: https://www.amazon.com/dp/1735160962 
Kindle: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0DCGGZX3K 
______________________
- Support the channel: https://www.patreon.com/branham 
- Visit the website: https://william-branham.org 

Show transcript Hide transcript
Episode transcript

Transcript

Music Hello and welcome to another episode of the William Blanham Historical Research Podcast. I'm your host, John Collins, the author and founder of William Blanham Historical Research at William-Branham.org, and with me I have my co-host, minister, and friend, Chen O'Ross, pastor and the voice of the understanding scripture and truth by Chen O'Ross, YouTube channel. Chen O'Ross, it's good to be back and last time I said that the podcast was probably going to be one of the most powerful ones we did, and I think this one, which follows on its heels, is probably going to be one of the most relevant ones that we have

done, because we're going to be talking about the expectation of the manifested sons of God. Now, back in Latter-Rain in the 1940s, whenever all of this was really starting to develop, especially through the early 1950s, this was an anticipation of the developing Pentecostal Charismatic Movement, this predated Charismania. However, it was resurrected by Paul Cain and others in IHOPKC, Kansas City Fellowship, and it became the theme of many of the new apostolic reformation leaders, and the interesting part of all of this I grew up with the same understanding that Branham taught in the 40s 50s and 60s, that this was an anticipation for us, and that

we were expecting this thing would happen in our generation, as I wouldn't say it. Well, what I learned was the in our generation keep shifting forward and forward and forward, but with each shift, it becomes more destructive.

So it's like you have a foundational doctrine that's not quite biblical, but you can maybe with a sledgehammer beaded in there, and then as it resurrects itself, it resurrects itself in the purest more evil form possible, and it continues to happen again. So this is very relevant, and I'm a little excited to get into this one as well. Well, it's the same, I guess, John, as when Jesus did not return in 1988, so the 88 reasons for him to return in 1988, you just got to rewrite all of that, and that's a problem with his

date setting and expecting all of these things to happen in our lifetime. We've got a lot of different things to try to pull together concerning this manifestation of the sons of God, and I know most people probably listen to the podcast rather than actually watch them So, I thought I would just read a couple of these verses in Romans chapter 8.

This is the basis. This is the text that the manifestation of the sons of God teaching is based on. And I think maybe most people are somewhat familiar with it, but here's what Paul said in Romans 8 verses 18. He said, I reckon that the sufferings of this present time are not worthy to be compared with the glory which shall be revealed in us. You know, when you read a passage like that, people who are looking for glory get pretty excited because they have an anticipation of something to happen. For the earnest expectation of the creation waited for the manifestation of the sons of God.

And there is the actual phrase that this movement and this doctrine was based upon. And people, if they care, can go on and read the next couple of verses there. And I have said before in talking about Dr. Freeman that this, that this very word, this big five syllable word manifestation was a big word in Freeman's whole teaching ministry.

And we've seen it on two earlier occasions. One in his teaching on the Trinity, which I think Dr. Freeman was in some degree of error on. And we did, I think, two podcasts on that John a long time ago. And his error, I believe, spring from the influence he had with William Brannum's teaching. Brannum sometimes was Trinitarian and sometimes Oneness, depending on his audience. Dr. Freeman had been trained in the seminary to be an orthodox Trinitarian believer, which would say something like this that God is one in essence, but three in person. And Hobart hated that after he became charismatic. He would never say that. He hated the

word person. He said, God is we are people. God is not a person. And his infamous definition for the Trinity was this that God is one divine spirit who eternally manifests. There's that word manifestation who eternally manifests himself as father, son, and Holy Spirit. I think he was really confused on quantitative, qualitative concepts within the Trinity. And to be honest, we have to face the fact there's no human being alive that fully understands or comprehends the the doctrine of the Trinity that God can be one in one or more senses in three in one or more

senses. I think he's one in one sense and he's three in another. And I think Hobart's view bordered on some type of a minor form of modalism. But anyway, he loved that word manifestation.

And the other place where we've seen manifestation is in all of their praying and claiming healing. They claim their healing, but then they're waiting for their manifestation. No one ever got healed when they asked to be healed as per the New Testament.

When Jesus or the apostles prayed for people, they didn't leave and say, well, now I've got to go home and confess it and act and endure and wait for my manifestation. That is just crazy charismatic nonsense.

None of that is in the New Testament. But it was what was taught by Kenneth Hagen that you believe when you believe you receive, when you pray, and then the manifestation is in God's timing.

That was Hobart Freeman's teaching. That is Andrew Walmax teaching today. It has never left the charismatic movement and probably never will. Where contrary to that in the New Testament, when people were prayed for to be healed, they were simply healed.

No one went away waiting for their manifestation. So those were two different areas where Hobart loved this big five-dollar, five-syllable word manifestation. And the third one, and maybe the most important one, is what we're talking about now.

Because that word actually does appear in the Bible, at least in the King James translation of the Bible, we are waiting or the creation is waiting for the manifestation of the sons of God.

What's interesting about that word, John, is if anyone cares to just look it up in their Greek New Testament, it's just the common word apocalyptic, which is the same word that has been given to the last book of the New Testament, the book of Revelation.

It means revelation. You could translate it in manifestation, but elsewhere in the New Testament, it's translated revelation that the creation is waiting for the revelation of the sons of God. So I think what Romans 8 is teaching is an experience rather than a ministry.

And what Hobart and the manifested sons of God people were teaching is that we are waiting for this ministry to be unfolded, that the manifested matured sons of God will get to go out and do and perform.

Where I think that most people in reading Romans 8 probably see this as an experience happening within the context of the second coming of Christ, where it talks about the whole creation has been plunged into its own misery.

And if we go... go back prior to the fall of Adam and Eve. You know, we see a Bountiful Lush Garden free from decay and death, and ever since the sin of the original couple, all the world has known.

The world, its animals, its vegetation, and us as people who live in the world, all the world has known is decay and corruption and eventually death. And what happened at the second advent is that Jesus overcomes death, and the way I think that probably most normal interpreters would understand Romans chapter eight is that, you know, as we're living in the world today, John, you and I, no one can tell the difference by looking at you and I and Adolf Hitler.

If we were standing in line together at the supermarket, you could not look at us and tell the difference. One of us is a Christian and one of us is not. And that's just the way the world is.

So way the world has been for a long time. The wheat and the tears are growing together and they're pretty much indistinguishable. But at the end of time, at the second advent, when Jesus returns, then as John said in first John 3.2, I quoted that verse last time, now we're the sons of God, but it doesn't yet appear what we shall be.

But we know that when he shall appear, we will be like him for we will see him as he is. I think this is talking about when Christ returns that the people of God will be seen to be the people of God and will be known to be the people of God, but this is not at all the way in which Hobart interpreted it.

Hobart took this passage not as an experience, but as a ministry that the whole creation out there is waiting for us to grow up, become the matured sons of God, so that we can be the ones to go out there and set them free.

General, you and I have had many conversations and we can understand each other pretty well. We both speak the same language. We have the same humor oddly enough in different ways, of course. But we have a common way to talk to each other that we really get each other.

My wife, when I married my wife, and I've visited my in-laws for the first time, and I'm telling all myself just a little bit I'm embarrassed myself because it makes sense for this example.

They love big words, love them. I don't understand how they find them. I don't understand where they get them, but they'll use a word in a sentence that I may have heard one time in my life if that, and I'm listening to it, and my mind just stops on that one word.

And I hear nothing they say after because I'm like, what in the world? I've never heard that word. before. Fast forward to now we've been married, I guess 30 years now. She'll, she'll kick me because I can't tell you the exact year. We, um, we still have conversations where she'll talk to me and she'll throw in one of those words. And I'm like, Jennifer, nobody uses that word. Well, we understand each other in different ways than language. And what I want, what I'm wanting to drive at is this. So you and I have a conversation and we can understand

people who have recently escaped, they even struggle further. And I can say this truly because in what you just said and where my mind went because of the loaded language, I missed it until I stopped and thought about it. So you're correct. The word manifestation could also mean revelation.

But to a person who's been overloading that word revelation into another category altogether, you still miss it because your mind went somewhere that the word actually isn't saying. So I'm going to put on my preacher hat and pretend I'm a preacher. I'm not. But here's the point I want to make. And I use this in another podcast that's kind of funny. I started studying the Greek language as I was reading the Bible over and over washing all of this out of my head, not to become a Greek scholar, but I would use the inner linear Bible and line up the words and meanings and try to figure

okay, what's it actually saying? And I learned that the Greek language is more complex than the English language. There are words like love that have so many different meanings, so many in the Greek.

And where we might say in our language, we might say, I love my wife. Well in Greek, they had specific words that go with it that make it it's a romantic love. But I could also in the English language say, I love Doritos, which doesn't mean the same thing at all. But in English, it's so dumbed down and simplified. And Greek, you have to understand the full context of what love is. Well, the point I'm trying to make is this, when I began that exercise, I'm reading inner linear and understanding that you can't love Doritos in the same way that you love your wife. You have to

understand how the language fits together. I started reading the Bible for simpler terms, like I would talk to you, not like my wife would talk to me. And to put my preacher hat on, Paul is standing before a group of people in a world where Christianity has not grown into what it is today. It's just a small group. And he says, your children of God, you, he's talking, I'm assuming he's talking to me and your sons of God in our world. That means nothing. That's not been overloaded in our language.

You are just children of God. And he says, right now we're nothing. And he's looking at a sickly crowd, they're weak, they're poor. Right now you're nothing but one day people of the world are going to know what Christianity is. And I'm using today's language for the same exact thing that isn't that passage. One day you're going to know what Christianity is.

And Jesus will return and he will come get us. And you can go into the passage, you can read everything that I just said using the interlinear. Now I'm not saying that I'm the best at translating anything like this.

But what I'm trying to say is people like Hobart, like Brannum, like his predecessors, all of these people tried to pray on the innocent who didn't understand the words that were used. It would be in the same scenario where if I went at my in-laws and they tried to manipulate my head because they're using these words I don't know, they did and they were actually teaching me as I was going.

But if they use that to their advantage over me to control and manipulate me, that's purely evil. And I would probably never go visit my in-laws again. But think of this, you go let a preacher do it and then you go back next Sunday because you're allowing him to do this.

And today's world, we have tools online, like you can go to Bible Hub, Bible Gateway, there's a few different ones. And you can see what the words actually mean. And I highly recommend if somebody's coming up with this weird doctrine that is outside of mainstream, you really need to check and see, is it something that's actually from the Bible or did it come from somebody's opinion?

I think that's very fair what you just said, John, even with your preacher's head on, a non-preacher wearing a preacher's head. I think that is very fair. And that is, I think if you were just reading through your New Testament, again, without the background of the loaded language, you'd end up probably with maybe not an exact precise understanding of Romans 8, but you certainly wouldn't end up where Brannem and Hobart did.

And as I said last time, last week, I had never heard of this doctrine of the manifestation of the sons of God. And as I said last week also, I'm sure I had read my whole Bible from cover to cover, at least once, probably twice by the time I heard Hobart.

And I never got that. I never got his view and the people are wondering, well, what was his view? As I said, his view is that what's being talked about in Romans 8 is this ministry that we're all waiting on.

We've got a mature and grow up. And then we're gonna get to be part of the manifestation of the sons of God. It's something God's waiting on us to mature so that he can show the world how mature we are.

And that is not what the passage is saying at all. It's an experience that we're going to have as well as the rest of creation. It seems like the second advent and our revelation, if you wanna use that word, which is the Greek word apocalyptic, or our manifestation happens at the second advent.

And then we'll lead to other things that Jesus will do on the earth. But after hearing what Hobart talked about, it. It's not that we are so much going to be manifested, but it's that and then God is going to deliver the creation, but that we in our manifestation will be the ones who go and deliver the groaning creation. And of course, anyone, any objective person would have to admit the text does not say that. It says we're going to be manifested. It says the groaning creation is going to be delivered, but it does not say that we're the ones who will deliver the creation. And that is

clearly and obviously beyond our capacity. That is something that God will do himself. But Hobart, because the phrase is there, John, he would say, no, don't be afraid of Romans 8. Don't be afraid of Romans 8. It's in the Bible. Don't be afraid of the doctrine of the manifestation of the sons of God. It's in the Bible. And I would say, yeah, the doctrine of the manifestation of the sons of God is in the Bible, but not your doctrine. Your take on it is not what is said there. And I just think he he sold them a bill of goods. It was the rabbit on the

racetrack running in front of those Greyhound dogs. And it was the doctrine that Dr. Freeman used to encourage everyone. Now is the time of preparation. Now is the time to discipline yourself in prayer and in Bible study and in overcoming your trials. All of his teaching about faith and overcoming and healing and everything, all of his teaching was geared toward the manifestation of the sons of God. It wasn't he would always say none of this is an end in itself. Faith is not an end in itself.

Deliverance is not an end in itself. Prosperity is not all there is. We are doing this in preparation for the restoration of all things in the manifestation of our sonship. And so a lot of that's why I think a lot of his teaching on faith and healing would work out in such a way that nothing ever really happened. You're always waiting on something to happen. And this waiting period is the trial of your faith. And you know, there are plenty of passages in the Bible like in James 1 and in 1st Peter 1 that talk about the trial of your faith. He didn't see the trial of your faith as maybe

some type of persecution like the early church experience and acts. The trial of your faith is when you went up and asked for prayer for healing and you didn't feel any better when you got back home and you didn't feel any better next week. And that is the trial of your faith. Everything, everything, John, at faith assembly was a trial. Everything was a trial.

If the washing machine broke down, that's a trial. If you didn't have gas for your car, that's a trial. If your wife said a crossword to you that morning before you left for work, that's a trial. Nothing was reality. And nothing came about, nothing was your own fault because you did something foolish or dumb. That might be why you're out of gas. You did not fill up the night before when you passed the gas station. Every single experience in the life of everybody at faith assembly was a trial. Nothing was reality. Nobody was sick. You couldn't say you were sick

because that would be a negative confession because you had prayed to be healed. So if you prayed to be healed, Mark 1124, and you received your healing when you prayed, then you're not sick.

But what are you? I'm experiencing a trial of my faith. And they lived in a world of complete lack of reality. Dr. Freeman would talk about if you people can't deliver yourself from a simple headache, then how can you deliver this groaning creation? He would use that as a point of reference all the time. If you can't deliver yourself from a simple headache. So he saw a headache as being something directly from Satan. It is a sickness, a pain, an illness, a disease, and cordoned Isaiah 53. We have been delivered from that. You know, the more I listened to him, and I was

I was young, but I wasn't too young not to continue to listen and then think, well, now wait a minute. You're saying even a headache? I mean, I might could understand back then that cancer is somehow from the devil and Jesus bore all of our cancer on the cross. I could probably back then accept that.

But when it got down to a headache, I had headaches because I was a normal human being and sometimes just in college, you read with dim light for too long. And the strain on your eyes gives you what? Gives you a headache. I don't think that came from Satan. And I don't think that was something Jesus bore on the cross. He went to the cross and died so that because I studied too long and too late at night in dim light conditions in college to take an exam. And I have a headache as a result from that. That is the part of the message of the cross. You know, that to

me just went way beyond the bounds of reality. I thought there's probably a lot of things. A lot of us are experiencing because of genetics, because of poor diet, because of not enough white because of not enough sleep, because of dehydration, because of stress, I thought that Dr. Freeman was so incredibly shallow on his views on healing and faith. I didn't think he had any worked out theology of divine healing, like he tried to have on other things.

I don't think he succeeded on other things, but I don't even think he tried on divine healing. He didn't have it worked out at all. I think we've talked about this before when it comes to healing. If you can't deliver yourself from a simple headache, then there's no way you can be a mature son of God. I think we talked about this earlier that his whole approach to Isaiah 53 with both sickness and sin in the atonement. There was something that was completely not right and out of balance with that, and the way I just processed it logically early on was

like this. I definitely believe that the punishment for our sin was born by Jesus on the cross, but sin is something that we do. Sin is something or that we don't do, something that we're commanded to do that we don't or something we are forbidden to do and we do.

We commit sin in thought and act indeed. That's what we do. We are sinners by nature. And when we are born again, Christ has born our sin for us, but sickness is something entirely different. Sickness and illness and disease and pain, those aren't things that we've done.

Those are just things that came on us that happened to us, not necessarily through any fault of our own. Where sin is definitely our own fault, sickness wasn't. So my mind, and it was a young mind, but it began to process and ask questions along the line of, then how can those equally be carried in the same way by the same Savior on the same cross, and so that all I have to do for sin is ask forgiveness, and then all I have to do for sickness is ask for healing. And then I took it a step further, John. How is it that when

I go and ask for forgiveness, I know that I've been forgiven. I'm not waiting for the manifestation of the forgiveness of my sin. I know that it's been done. But when I pray for my healing, I have to wait for the manifestation of my healing. None of it squared in my mind, none of it made any sense. It just didn't even seem to be logical at the end of the day.

Have you ever wondered how the Pentecostal movement started or how the prayer was? Greshan of modern Pentecostalism, transition through the latter reign, charismatic and other fringe movements into the new Apostolic Reformation, you can learn this and more on William Brannum Historical Research's website, William-Brannum.org.

On the book's page of the website, you can find the compiled research of John Collins, Charles Paisley, Stephen Montgomery, John McKinnon, and others with links to the paper, audio, and digital versions of each book. You can also find resources and documentation on various people and topics related to those movements.

If you want to contribute to the cause, you can support the podcast by clicking the contribute button at the top. And as always, be sure to like and subscribe to the audio or video version that you're listening to or watching.

On behalf of William Brannum Historical Research, we want to thank you for your support. One of the problems that came from this movement was that there were a lot of people who were inducted into the ministry simply by the laying on of hands and prophesying over them.

And they had no theological training, but they wanted to be bigger than they actually were. And what happened was you had this strange mix, you had people who came in who really didn't know the Bible, who became teachers of the Bible, but you also had some legitimate teachers of the Bible who came in. Hobart would be one of the more legitimate, in some cases.

But during the 40s and 50s, as this thing was developing, you had that weird mix. Well, what happened, and this is my opinion, there's no way to go back and actually trace all of this down. But in my opinion, what happened is this, some of the people did have basic understanding of Greek in their theological training, but they were explaining it to people who didn't understand the concept that I did with love. You know, you can have different types of love in the text. So what they did was they took all of the different varying meanings of the

word, and then they ran rampant with it. In other words, they saw a word, and they thought, well, that's a powerful word. It means all of these other things. And then they would go teach all of these other things, not understanding that you had to put it into the context of that scripture. And one of the words, I did some deep studies on this because I came out of this.

One of the words, and I'll never pronounce it. So I had to get the spelling. So I can spell it. H-U-I-O-S. It just simply means son or sons. That's where this came from. There's nothing in the text that says even that it is a really the mature aspect that they give it.

It's just simply this is a son. You're a son of God. But it has gone so far in today's world that they have injected the theme of the manifest, but also maturity. They're injecting maturity into this. It's not just a son. It's a mature son because you can kind of take the Greek and go that way if you want to.

So then you find all of these mature sun doctrines, and that's kind of, I guess that would be the background of what came in and developed before Hobart came into the picture. So with the maturity, now you get to take it into today's world, it's a mature air. So you've got the air doctrine, HEIR doctrines that come in.

It's an air, it's a governing. Now you've got the seven mountains, mandate, you've got all of the things where we're to come in as mature sons of God, the manifested sons of God, and govern the people.

What they're doing is they're injecting and stacking doctrines on top of doctrines, not even going back to the root to try to even understand what was Paul actually saying in that passage. So for me, I wiped all of that out of my memory. I tried to go back to a blank slate and just say, okay, what was actually said, and what have they added to it?

And if you put it into a balanced scale, the stuff they added is like, it's so weighty that you can't even make the Bible resemble what it actually said in the end. And you and I say this all the time, John, what people need to do more than anything is read their own Bible. Forget, forget everything else, forget the recorded messages of random and Freeman, and simply go and read the Bible for themselves. You will, you will learn so much.

But in the process, I know you have spoken about this at length when you first were out of the movement and you tried to read the Bible, you're still reading the Bible through the lens of the people that have taught you.

And so when you see these words, they are, as you often say, loaded language, and they bring to your mind and to your whole psyche, you know, all of this stuff, these feelings and just the baggage that comes with that.

But over time, you get cleansed from that just by reading the Bible and trying to, you know, I'd say just on Romans 8, just try to put out of your mind anybody's interpretation of Romans 8 and read it for yourself.

And then go back and say now, I don't think I got the manifestation of the sons of God that this is some end time ministry that we are going to be the ones if we can mature enough to go out and deliver this groaning creation.

You wouldn't get that. I didn't get that when I read it after Hobart told me that, you know, you just have to continue to be taught false doctrine before it finally becomes a part of you because it's not in the passage there.

And I'm so glad you brought up the topic of sons versus children. We have not talked about this with regard to Hobart. But as you can imagine, oh boy, was this a big part of his doctrine? The reason you have a difficult time pronouncing that who else that word in Greek for sons?

And it's because that word has what we call a rough breathing mark over it. You know, when I went to college, in my undergraduate days, I was 18 years old, I was a freshman in college.

I didn't know much, but I knew that I had been called to the ministry. I didn't know how that would ever unfold and know how that would happen. And even though I was in a secular university, I decided I'll take every class, I possibly can, that hopefully, you know, one day in the future, I had no idea when that would be or how it would come about these classes and what I've learned can help me.

So I took classical Greek, which you don't do at the University of Mississippi. There's no reason to be taking Greek when you're a freshman in college. But I took it then and also had it in seminary.

So you have a rough breathing mark, which puts an H in front of a word, if you have a smooth breathing mark, then that H is silent, you don't pronounce that or you don't have any pronunciation there.

That's a little bit on the Greek. But the business of children and sons, that was huge in Hobart's ministry. And again, it was something, John, I had to be taught. Reading the Bible didn't tell me that there is this huge chasm, this huge difference between being a child of God and being a son of God.

I kind of assume they're probably the same thing. If you're a child of God, you're probably a son of God. But that is not the case with the matured sons of God, manifested sons of God teaching.

So what Hobart taught, and there are two different Greek words for sure, one for children or child and one for son. What Hobart taught was that everyone is a child of God. But not every child of, every every Christian is a child of God, but not every child of God is a son of God.

So children, he taught was the inclusive term, all of God's people, all of people who've been born again and saved and washed in the blood, all of those people are children of God, but not all children are sons of God.

And so then here you come with these levels of Christianity. If you are a John 3, 16 person, you're just one of those lowly children of God. But if you're a Romans eight person, you are a son of God.

And he had a teaching I remember listening. Yeah, and he did this often, but it was from Galatians four, where I think Paul is really, I won't try to get into that because I'm doing all that for memory, where Paul is really contrasting.

listing the Old Testament Jewish system, where they were more like slaves of God. And he said, and we are the sons of God. Hobart didn't contrast the Jewish way versus a Christian way. He contrasted the merely Christian way with the matured Christian way, children versus sons.

And I think he took, I think he took every bit of this from Brannum and from whoever was teaching this type of stuff prior to Brannum or during Brannum's time. And when I read the Bible and I see there are passages that call us children of God and passages that call us sons of God, I think that probably what's happening there in the New Testament, and this is just what I think why there are different words, is that those are two different metaphors.

They're still referring to the same group of people. If you're a child, you're a son, if you're a son, you're a child, but they're two different metaphors. One, when it talks about us as being the children of God, then it means that God has birthed us.

And that's the new birth experience. And in John chapter three, John's Gospel, where Jesus is talking to Nicodemus, where prior to that, we are, as he said in John 8.44, he told the Pharisees, you are of your father, the devil.

That's who your father is. You have not been birthed by God. You are not children of God. So when children of God appears, we're part of God's family. He is our father and he has birthed us.

Other passages refer to us as sons of God. Sons of God, and you say, well, what is that? I think that's also a metaphor because there was a right through which young boys would go at the age of 13, when they became legally adopted into this family.

And so again, even though we're children of God, we also have many verses in the New Testament that speak of our adoption into God's family because we don't naturally belong to his family. According to Paul and Ephesians chapter two, we are by nature, children of wrath.

We're not naturally the children of God, but he has adopted us graciously into his family. So I don't think you can make some huge distinction between children of God and sons of God. I think they refer to the same group of people, but they are using different metaphors.

And so it's coming at it from a different angle. But as you and I know, the matured sons of God, that became the big part of the manifestation of the sons of God. You had to, you couldn't just be a child and you really couldn't just be a child.

a son to be honest. You had to mature as a son. And so what was going to happen at the end of time, but prior to the return of Christ is that this growing, swelling body of the sons of God, that doesn't include all those regular Christians out there. These are the elite people. We are slowly maturing. We are maturing through our trials. We're also, as you know, John, maturing through the equipping of the five-fold ministry. They always brought Ephesians 4 into it. God gave those apostles and prophets, et cetera, so that we, today, here at the end of time, we could mature,

so through our trials, through the giving of the five-fold ministry, through these various avenues. God is maturing not every believer, just a small elite select group of people. They would become the matured sons of God. They would therefore be manifested as God's sons. And their manifestation would occur as they deliver this groaning creation from its corruption and bondage.

That is how you would put all of that together in a nutshell. What's funny is Hobart came from Baptist seminary, right here in this area, and the way that he taught the sonship is much like you would say about bourbon. All bourbon is whiskey, but not all whiskey is bourbon. But that's not at all what Paul is saying. If you read this, and again, I'm not a Greek scholar. I'm just an average guy who's reading it. But the words aren't that hard. You really have to inject a lot of things to make it say what they're trying to say. But think about where that went. If you go to jonestown.sdsu.edu,

you can find all of my research that has been published on Jim Jones and People's Temple. When you think of the word cult, that's where everybody goes to People's Temple in Jonestown, Guyana. This was one of the most horrific events, and this is what actually branded cult as a destructive evil thing. Cult just simply means a cult following a people.

Jones taught the hierarchy level sonship that you're talking about. I have some research published about this, but he's talking about the manifestation, and he says something to the effect that my manifestation is greater than your manifestation. So this became a hierarchy, but more than that, it actually, this would have been in the 70s that he's saying this if I remember correctly, you have to go look it up and see if I'm right. But in around the late 70s, early mid 70s, I think it was, they started to come up with a concept that this sonship, this manifested sons,

was a credential for authority. You, if you were a manifested son, you had authority over the people who did not. So like Hobart said, there's children of God and their sons of God, well, you would have a tutorial.

for those children of God. Well then, the leaders of you had to have a greater manifestation so they would be leaders of the leaders of the people. And it's such a mess when you try to think that you cannot make the text say that and look where it got Jones and his people.

Jones was part of this movement that taught all of this. So now fast forward to today. You have a large number of people in the New Apostolic Reformation who are teaching the same thing, but like I said, it gets worse with each reinterpretation.

Now they have added dominion on top of what I just said. You have authority over those people and you're going to go take dominion over them. Once you add all of these pieces together, you literally are bringing people back into the days of the Holy Wars.

You're wanting to go conquer. And that's not at all what Paul is saying in this passage, but that's where it developed and what it developed into. We probably see that in some current ministries like the Ministry of Mark Driscoll, who was, I guess he was the pastor of the famous Mars Hill Church and that all imploded and then he started a new church down in Texas, I think called Trinity.

And oh, my goodness, is there domination involved there? And there was domination at Faith Assembly. I mean, Hobart was, he was the leader. You know, he was the head. No one could challenge him.

No one could question him. And you're so right about, so many ministers had no formal, theological, training or understanding at all. And if people say, well, I don't think a minister should, well, how is it in any other field of life, in any field, from electrician to automobile mechanics to a medical doctor?

You have to have some training. You can't just hang a shingle outside your door and, you know, say, I am Dr. Will Practice. You know, you have to, you have to have some training.

And yet there's such an anti-schooling, anti-intellectual, anti-education thrust in the whole history of the Pentecostal and Charismatic Movement, that, you know, higher training is just outlawed, frowned upon greatly. Unless you want to start your own school, like Christ for the Nations or Rema or something, but then all you're doing is you're just, that's just in bread.

You're just training them, the stuff you want them to believe. Where when you really go for higher training, you hear all the views, you know, you hear what the professor thinks is a correct view, but you hear some opponents views as well.

Faith assembly was so lacking. Faith assembly, Faith assembly did the same thing, Gordon Lindsay and Kenneth Hagen did. They created their own little school and it was called the Charismatic School and there was one professor and that was Hobart Freeman and he taught every- thing, Old Testament survey, New Testament survey, Biblical theology, Old Testament theology, New Testament theology, he taught it all. So you're, you're being indoctrinated by one individual.

That's never wise. That's never safe. You know, what medical doctor would go to school and take all of their classes just from one professor. You know, what, what automobile mechanic would go to school and say, I only want to learn from this person. There's so many other people that know things that can supplement what the main teacher might know and have to say. So they were so bereft and starved for real theological training among the ministers at faith assembly.

And you know, my story was I never ended up at faith assembly. And I probably would have had I not followed my parents, not wishes, but demands that I go and get an undergraduate degree from a secular university. And I did. And I graduated in three years and set a four years. And I didn't decide to do that until the start of my third year. So I had to take 34 semester hours, my next to last semester and 24 my last because I, I did want to get out. But once I got out, I didn't move

to Northern Indiana. You know, I immediately went into the ministry and I didn't know a whole lot, but what early, the early years of my ministry, what that did for me is it gave me time.

It gave me time to read and study because I was in a full-time ministry. And I was teaching a lot, but I still, it was full-time ministry. So I had time to read and to study. And that's exactly what I did. And invariably what that does is it broadens your horizons. And invariably what that does, whether you are self-taught or whether you are in a formal setting, if you will discipline yourself and dedicate yourself to study, it will educate you. And you will see not only maybe some inconsistencies with what your mentor, my mentor, Hobart Freeman was saying, but more than

inconsistencies just flat out wrong. That is not what the Hebrew said. That is not what the Greek says. That can't be found anywhere in the Bible. Just flat out wrong. And then when you see things that not really, it's not interpretation. It's just flat out wrong, flat out not there.

All of a sudden, you know, John, what happens. Your whole world and theology kind of caves in on you. It just implodes. And then you have to start building from scratch all over again.

We did a podcast. I'm reminded, John, just a few weeks ago on the former and latter reign. That terminology has, for over 100 years, dominated they did the Pentecostal and Charismatic Movement. And yet, as I said then, and I would say now would challenge anybody to find a verse in the Bible that talks about former and latter reign in the context of some giving of the Holy Spirit.

It's simply not there. But people have always been taught that. It sounds good. We said in that podcast that the Holy Spirit and reign and water are definitely found in various contexts in the Old and the New Testament.

The very phrase, the outpouring of the Holy Spirit has the connotation of reign. But those terms, former reign and latter reign, which became technical terms in the Pentecostal movement, they're not used in either the Old or the New Testament with regard to the coming of the Holy Spirit.

And I'm kind of glad that they aren't. Because there would be even bigger battles than there have been over trying to identify the date of the former versus the date of the latter reign.

On some of Hobart's tapes, he'll say, well, the former reign was what happened with Peter and the people on the day of Pentecost. And the latter reign is what's happening now. But then on other tapes, this is how crazy it becomes.

On other recorded messages, Hobart would say, well, the latter reign was what happened in 1901 and to Pika, Kansas, and then later in Azusa Street. And with people like Amy, Simple McPherson and William Seymour and all of those people.

And what we're experiencing, we as in Hobart in 1960s and 70s, what we are experiencing, that's the latter reign. Former reign, early century latter reign, 60s and 70s. And then in the third place, Sean, on other messages, the former reign is what was happening then during the 60s and 70s.

And this latter reign will be the manifestation of the sons of God, the matured sons of God being revealed to the world. So there was not only no agreement on former and latter reign, there was no consistency in Hobart's own mind.

It just depended on what period in his ministry he were listening to cassette tapes. So it just became really, really difficult to interpret all that. Let me go in one small, slight new direction with the time we have left, John.

There was another way, there was another way that Hobart used to trick people into believing him. And you just have to hold on for a minute and you'll hopefully understand where I'm going with this.

So he knew that people had heard of the manifestation of the sons of God in his audience. I had, I had not heard of that, but he knew that some people had. So whenever he would bring up Romans eight, or the manifestation of the sons of God, he would say, now, we're not talking about the extreme manifested sons people. So you got to picture me as 17, 18, 19 years old. I didn't even know what the non-extreme manifested sons people were, let alone the extreme. But as you listen and he explains, then, then you quickly catch on. And he loved to tell this story of being

at, he had spoken at a full gospel businessmen's local meeting. And the, the local chapter leader had hope art to his home, I think, for, you know, lunch or dinner afterwards. And the leader's wife was telling Hobart about this, this, this manifested sons of God, this, this terrible, horrible teaching about the manifestation of the sons of God. And how it was just creating havoc within the full gospel businessmen's fellowship international.

And, you know, circle, that, that circle in the different chapters were being divided and churches were being divided. And she said, oh, it's just awful. It's just horrible. This is the story Hobart would tell. And he, and then here, here comes a punchline. And he would say, oh, really? Really? You know, he knew what she meant by that, but he pretended like he didn't. And he said, so this terrible teaching on the manifested manifestation of the sons of God, just what is that? And the chapter leader's wife said, oh, I don't know, but it's awful. It's awful. And Hobart used that to tell people that the manifestation

of the sons of God teaching has a bad rap, but people really don't know. They just think it's bad. They've heard it's bad. They come to believe that it's bad, but they really don't know what the teaching is of the manifestation of the sons of God. However, he would distance himself from what he called the extreme manifested sons of God. And I didn't even know what that meant. You know, later I came to believe that his view is an extreme view of the manifestation of the sons of God. But what did he mean by that? There were some people who had, who had

taken that doctrine and who had taken it, I guess you could say a step or two further down the line where they came to deny the second advent and they came to deny that there would be any catching away or rapture of the church so that they themselves could have Christ being seen in them, therefore there's no need for Christ to return.

His return is happening in us and he called this the extreme view of the manifested sons of God. And there was a minister down in Alabama who had gotten his teaching from Dr. Freeman who had actually traveled up to the barn and had sung for them and maybe had taught there.

His name was Eugene May, I knew him very well because he came to our church in Memphis in Talt and Hobart began receiving some letters from the people in Gene May's church and in his outreach saying, here's what now, here's what Eugene May is now teaching.

And Eugene May and I received some of his newsletters and I saw the teaching in there. He began to be influenced by a guy named Bill Britton and Bill Britton had been influenced by another man by the name of George Warnock.

And I know you're familiar with George Warnock. Warnock had written a really, it's an interesting and influential book in 1951 called The Feast of Tabernacles and what Warnock had come to believe, he knew, I mean, all of these people, John, were so mystical.

They're just delving into things way beyond their pain grade. But he knew that in Old Testament Israel, there were three, what we could call annual feasts where pilgrimages were made by Jewish men back to Jerusalem if they lived outside of the Jerusalem area.

They would go back on Passover and Pentecost and Tabernacles. Those were the three regular annual feasts. And Warnock saw deep spiritual meanings and the three feast. He saw in the feast of Passover, the crucifixion of Christ.

He saw in the feast of Pentecost, obviously the outpouring of the Holy Spirit. So here are those three steps or we could call the three groups of Christians. You got your just boring Christian.

All he is is a John 3, 16, one. He has the feast of Passover. You have Charismatics and Pentecostals. They've experienced the Feast of Pentecost. But what we are still waiting for is the future Feast of Tabernacles.

And that is exactly what Dr. Freeman taught as well. And that the Feast of Tabernacles would be the manifestation of the sons of God. And I know you have done some quite a bit of study in that area, so I'll let you chime in.

The only thing that I'll bring in is that Warnock was earned Baxter's personal secretary. Baxter was William Bram's campaign manager and one of the five heads of the Shepparding Movement, the one that's really launching the framework of control.

And for me, it all... comes down to this. I heard the most refreshing thing said from a minister after I left the cult. He was reading the Bible and he says, I don't understand that. I've not heard that in all of my 37 years in the cult, not a minister says this because they have to know everything. Otherwise, they're not speaking with the ramah or the spoken word. They have to know. But this minister said, you know, I just don't understand that. When that phrase hit my ear, it opened my world because now you've opened the door for, well, if you try

to make the Bible say something it doesn't say, number one, you can make it say something that's in disagreement with other parts of the Bible. And number two, you might be completely wrong anyway. And so this guy just said, I'm not going to be completely wrong. I'm just going to say, but here's the problem. Think about the maturity. And I don't care if you're talking about from when manifested sons came in through Brannemism or Warnock or Jim Jones and people's temple or Hobart Freeman or Paul Kane, Mike Pickle, you can go all the way down the whole, the whole array of people when they're teaching the mature sons and

they're in a letter from Paul. How can you make that reconcile with what Paul describes as maturity? It's very plainly written in the Bible, maturity is love, long suffering, self control, all of the things that is polar opposite to the entire movements hierarchy.

Paul says that is Christian maturity. So for me, had all of these people just simply said, I read this thing about manifested sons and I'll be honest, I don't know what that manifested word means. I would have been okay with it. But what they did is they just barreled down like a bull in a china shop and said, we're going to make a doctrine on this and build on top of it and on top of it. To the extent, we're going to end up trying to take dominion over other countries. That's how bad this has gotten. And it all started

with that one error. Just somebody who was unwilling to say, I don't really understand what that says. So thank you for being willing to share what it actually says. And also for the pronunciation of that word because I was struggling.

Well, John, there's a lot of things in the Bible. I don't know. I only teach in the areas where I feel confident and comfortable, but you're so right. Hobart never said, that's a passage I really struggle with. But if any of us would look in the mirror and be honest, there are a lot of passages that all of us struggle with. There are a lot that we don't struggle with that we're very confident in our view and interpretation. And we should be, but you are so right. That is so refreshing to see and hear humility in a Christian minister.

And I don't think you find it in our circles. I think you find it in other circles. You'll definitely find it with trained seminary professors because so much of their training is in a particular area of biblical studies, and they aren't that familiar with some other area. And the Bible is vast. So we need to all give one another plenty of room to say, you know, that's a verse or a text or a chapter that I just haven't spent enough time with. So rather than just launch out into the deep and be a fool, I'm just going to suspend judgment on that for right now.

Absolutely. Well, if you've enjoyed our show and you want more information, you can check us out on the web. You can find us at William-Branum.org. From more about the dark side of the New Apostolic Reformation, you can read Weaponized Religion from Christian Identity to the NAR, available on Amazon, Kindle, and Audible.