Podcast Episode

Obey Your Leaders? The History Behind Hebrews 13:17

John examines Hebrews 13:17 and the history behind the familiar command to "obey them that have the rule over you." Beginning with the Greek wording behind "obey," he compares the passage with early Christian leadersh...

2026, November 2 00:54:49 17 tags

John examines Hebrews 13:17 and the history behind the familiar command to "obey them that have the rule over you." Beginning with the Greek wording behind "obey," he compares the passage with early Christian leadership structures and explains why the modern image of a single pastor ruling a congregation does not neatly match the earliest Christian communities.

John then traces the development of Christian authority through Ignatius, Irenaeus, the Reformation, William Branham, the Shepherding Movement, and the New Apostolic Reformation. The central question is not whether all church authority is wrong, but how Christians came to organize authority, why those structures repeatedly developed, and what can happen when Hebrews 13:17 is used to demand unquestioning submission.

______________________
Weaponized Religion: From Christian Identity to the NAR:
Paperback: https://www.amazon.com/dp/1735160962 
Kindle: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0DCGGZX3K 
______________________
- Support the channel: https://www.patreon.com/branham 
- Visit the website: https://william-branham.org 

Show transcript Hide transcript
Episode transcript

Transcript

Music Hello and welcome to another episode of the William Brandham Historical Research Podcast. I'm your host, John Collins, the author and founder of William Brandham Historical Research at William-Brandom.org, where history proves that truth, or at least that her version of it, is truly stranger than fiction.

I was asked recently in the comment feeds, and you may have actually seen it on YouTube if you were following the discussion. I was asked about the passage from Hebrews 13, specifically Hebrews 13, 17. And I avoid theology as everybody knows. I'm not a theologian, I'm not a preacher, I don't claim to be never really wanted to be. But this is an important passage of Scripture because this is the Scripture that ruined my life. And when I say ruined, I'm saying that loosely. I actually had a relatively good life when I was in the destructive cult that we escaped. But it could have been such more of a fulfilling life.

I guess that's probably the best way to say it. Now there are people who it absolutely does ruin their lives. And this is a very destructive verse if handled improperly. And I want to talk through that because there's some history behind it. And this is one of the examples that I can talk about the Bible, but I can actually focus on history instead of theology and help people to understand why they have been abused and beaten with the Bible. And I, for those who are unaware, this series that I do by myself, I've titled it Weaponized Religion because truly they have weaponized the Bible against the people.

And it has been to the benefit of some very destructive leaders. This verse in question, Hebrews 13, 17, has been used by numerous high-demand groups, high-control groups to claim that they have, they being the ministers or the central figures, have the authority to do with whatever they will to the people. And it's destructive. It is weaponizing the Bible against the people. And in this way, the Bible simply becomes a ballbat that you smack the people with. And that's not what it is intended to be, nor was that how the Bible was viewed by both the early Christians and predating the New Testament by the Jews.

This was not intended to be this way, but I want to talk to that history because it is really, really important. For those of you who are unfamiliar with the verse, I'll read it in the King James English to satisfy those who are KJV only.

The verse says, Obey them that have rule over you and submit yourselves for they watch over your souls as they must give account that they may do it with joy, not with grief, for that is unprofitable for you.

So for those of you listening who were in one of the destructive groups like I mentioned my family escaped, you heard this verse and suddenly you were triggered. Instantly, you had whips and chains in the back of your minds because that is how this verse is viewed by the high demand, high control groups.

When you listen to the words in today's English, and this was King James Version, so this was written 1611, Obey them that have rule over you. That phrase rule over you, suddenly that's in the back of your mind.

The second thing, submit yourselves. I can't tell you how many sermons that I heard growing up about submitting yourself to the leaders and pastors would use it to no end. If they had an opinion and you did not like their opinion, you had to submit to their opinion in the high control group that we escaped.

Not every pastor was like this. We did actually have some good ones, but those who were full of themselves use this so that you could be full of themselves too. And I'm laughing at the absurdity, but that is how it was.

If you keep reading, it says, they watch over your souls because they must give an account. I also can't tell you how many sermons that I heard about this. They're the ones who are going to stand before God in the judgment day and give their account of you.

In other words, you mean nothing to God. It's them that means everything. And I heard that over and it was drilled into my head, man. In fact, we had the central figure, William Brannum, from whom all of this developed.

One was the one who spearheaded the post-war war to healing revivals, which developed into laterane, shepherding movement, charismatic movement, new apostolic reformation. This is the framework that he helped to establish in the United States in abroad so that he could claim that he was the one who would give an account to God on behalf of the people.

And he even claimed that he had a vision of him doing this on the other side. So we were listening to things like this and we listened to this passage, partially thinking, oh, we blessed us because he's going to do this and we mean nothing to God.

But on the other side, we're thinking, oh, I'm not sure if I really agree with that. So your mind is really torn between two dichotomies. Now the interesting part about this, fast forward, after my leaving and after I read the Bible for myself, over and over and over, I lost count of the number of times.

So I think I've mentioned 15 times or so. I just read a cover to cover for what it said. And I tried to ignore what I was trained to believe that it said. And here's… The thing that I found, which strongly applies to not only this passage, but you can apply it to every single thing in the Bible.

When you find two polar opposite opinions that are sometimes given by the same person who's writing, it might be Paul, it might be Peter, whoever. And one opinion says, you're free in Christ. No longer do you have to submit yourself to these people.

Why? Who has bewitched you that you're submitting yourself to these people? These are actual passages. You cannot make that come together with this, obey those who rule you. So either they are bipolar and they have some mental health problem while they're writing the Bible or we are not fully understanding what they're saying in one case or the other case or even both cases.

And the way that I try to tell people who I've worked with for years in the support groups is this. The English language is very, very difficult, especially when you're trying to find compatibility between an ancient language that we don't even have today and compatibility between the modern language today, there are words that just don't connect.

And you can complicate this further because the English language likes to overload the meaning of a single word, an example that I give is the word love. I love my wife. And when you hear this in English, you think, yes, John has a romantic relationship with his wife, he loves his wife, they have this bond because they are husband and wife.

But what if I told you that I also love Doritos? Your mind does not think that John has a romantic relationship with Doritos. It just does not work. But the English language is that complicated and that you have to understand the word by the surrounding words.

Not all languages are like this, and especially in the ancient Greek, they had so many different words for just the word love. And they had a divinely heavenly love, they had a romantic love, they had all different variants.

Well, there were words or phrases for each one of these, and what do you do with this? The King James translators, and practically every English translator after this, has to pick a word because you can only make one word fit.

But you don't really grasp what the original language was saying about that word. To solve this problem, sometimes they will take one word in the original Greek or Hebrew, and they will expand it into a phrase.

And so you find one word and you find a phrase, there is a tool for doing this. And I highly recommend if you have been trapped in one of these groups and you've been beaten over the head with the Bible.

This is what I did. I read the Bible over and over, like I said. Well, then I also went to my favorite tool today. I went to these tools that have interlinear versions. You can go to BibleHub.com and you can type in any verse, any chapter and you can click on the interlinear button and you'll find I'll pull it up for those who are watching on YouTube.

You can see this stack of words and numbers and this is very, very critical to understand because it is showing you exactly what I just described and they're clickable so you can go into them and see what the word or phrase means.

But more than that, it has a, the number is a strong concordance so you can click on the number itself and it will show you, we'll hear some other passages that use that same word.

So you can get not only the meaning and the broad complex connection between words. You can also see how it's used in other places in the Bible and that way you can find, in some cases, you can even find where the translators didn't quite get it right.

And so that's why modern translations have sometimes corrected this. For those of you who are watching on YouTube, I clicked the word obey, which is really the word in question whenever you think about this verse and how it's misused.

And the original word, the phrase that is given is to persuade, to convince, to trust and to have confidence, which sounds totally different than it does to us today when we hear the word obey.

But again, the word obey doesn't quite fit the exact meaning. They just had to choose an English word and that's what was chosen. The interesting part about this passage, however, is this. There's not that wide of a variety between all of the modern translations and the King James version.

And in the King James version, what I would say is not really a mistake, but they chose a very poor choice of wording in the King James version. They did not really deviate from that very much in many of the modern translations.

The new international version seems to have translated the word obey more correctly than all of the others. It does use the word have confidence. So for those of you who are KJV only and say that the modern translations are luring souls to hell.

And this is a clear example of a very, very different translation. The one that is in the NIV, the translation have confidence, is actually closer to the original Greek than the KJV. Are both right or wrong, not really, because they're both a translation, a modern translation, trying to fit a single word that fits the Greek phrase or word.

And it doesn't quite fit. So you can say that both are correct, but both have a different meaning in today's world. That's probably the best way to say it. Now what's interesting is the NIV, which I'll read for those who are listening and not watching, it says have confidence in your leaders and submit to their authority.

So the NIV people who haven't studied the original Greek will say, well this still says the same thing, it's the same meaning of the verse. says, submit to their authority because they keep watch over you as those who must give an account.

Do this so that their work will be a joy, not a burden, that it would be, for that would be no benefit to you. So when you compare the two passages, they're very, very close. The word confidence is used in NIV, the word obey, and most of the other translations. But the original Greek, again, was to persuade to convince, to trust, to have confidence. I would say that the NIV have confidence, for me, fits better because that fits better with the broad scope of what's being said throughout the Bible, not just this one passage. But I want to go deeper with that because there's some clear

history where this has been abused in multiple cases throughout time. And this has been a debating point just simply because the understanding of what it meant to be a leader in the religion was always a struggle from the dawn of time. And if you go back beyond the New Testament, all the way back into the Old Testament, there was always this hierarchy that existed. And whenever the New Testament apostles came, they started to flatten this where there's God, and here's everybody else. We're all one in Christ. Well, that flattening was a problem for many people, especially those

who felt like they had the need to lead other people. So it's always been a struggle, a power struggle, and I want to talk through that a bit as we get deeper in this podcast. The first thing I want to do is go back to the interlinear version because this is a very, very powerful tool, especially for people like me who do not understand Greek or Hebrew. And at the same time, if you don't know how the tool works, you can go way off into error. And it is a very simple tool to use once you figure it

out. The top line has the numbers. It's the strongest concordance, which I clicked on before. And the third line, you can see it's the bold black line on the page. It is the original Greek wording. Above that is the Greek word in our character set. You'll see the bold black is the Greek character set. Well, above it is our character set. And you'll see the bold black line right below it is red, which is the word that was translated used in the translation. Obey those leading you and be submissive. So this is laid out very clearly. It's very easy to use. You only really

need those four columns, but you can go deeper into, there's a fifth column that you can go to. And if you hover over it, it just simply gives you some information about the word. So this is a very, very easy tool to use, but it's also a very easy tool to abuse if you don't understand how this works. Because you can see these words that are translated in red don't exactly match what you read in Greek or Hebrew.

That's because the words and the original Greek and the character set were not arranged in the same way that they are in the King James Version or modern translations. They had to rearrange words to make it flow in our language. So you have to think of this more of a each word can mean a phrase or each phrase can mean a word.

You have to do the mapping kind of in your mind as you read it. But what this does is this gives you the power to understand why it's a difficult passage to understand in cases like this.

And I want to be clear if you think about this and you think about the difference between the word obey and the word persuade. There are people who might mistakenly say, well, this passage doesn't mean to obey at all. That's not quite true. There are some nuances.

And that's one thing that whenever you get into the theology side of things, a pastor who has studied the Greek can probably help you better than I can. But there are some nuances that go into theology. There are also some nuances that go into history. And that's where it gets interesting for me because think of it like this.

You had an original translation, the gospel spread, people translated to their own dialects and their own, there's many different families of Bibles as this is being transmitted around the globe. Well, people began to read these who could read and they started to understand it in their worldview and their worldview began to shape the theology.

And so there's a progression of original text, worldview, theology, transmission, and then the theology begins to evolve. And it evolves into what we have today and that's where for me, it gets to be a little bit troublesome in cases like this.

Because if you let it evolve in the wrong way, it can spend completely out of control. This is a clear example of that just simply based on history. And if you think logically about the transmission of this original text, it completely destroys the mental picture that you have of what has developed into the church today.

The church today just simply does not match it. Remember when this letter was written to the Hebrews, whenever the author said your leaders there was not anybody receiving that letter who was picturing what you and I picture today as someone who says he is or she is your pastor.

It just simply did not exist back then. The hierarchy and structure of the church comes much later. So your leader meant something entirely different than what you see today. In most Christian churches today, and I'm not talking about those who are destruct over high demand groups, you have a senior pastor, below them you have associate pastors, ministry leaders, below them you have elders, you have a board, below all of this structure, you have a congregation.

And sadly... This is the structure that matches the business model. Leadership in the earliest Christian churches, and you can read this according to some of the earliest Christian sources. It's talking about multiple leadership terms and functions, and it doesn't really give, there's no evidence that suggests that there's one universal adopted first century organizational chart.

The hierarchy that we have today just simply did not exist. Think of it more like a community. In the community, you had people who were teachers. In the community, you had people who were prophets.

In the community, you had people who were apostles. In the community, there were those who were overseers, and you can read that clearly in Acts or Titus. You also had deacons in the community.

You had elders in the community. You had people who were caring for God's flocks, shepherds of the movement. It was a community. If you didn't go to this church building and see a pulpit, and some guy who's in here, who we salary, that didn't exist back then.

Even the names that, if you watch the YouTube video, you saw on the slide, apostles, prophets, teachers, elders, overseers, deacons, all of these. When you hear that today, immediately because of the way that the laterane movement specifically, but other movements as well, bastardize that passage.

You begin to think fivefold ministry. You begin to think authority, hierarchy, control, and ultimately what you really are thinking about for those of you who are in business, you're thinking of a business pyramid.

You've got the CEO, under him, you've got the vice presidents, and you can go all the way down the line to the customers. And sadly, when you go to a church, you are a customer for their business.

Not that I'm disagreeing with church or anything like this, but they've adopted the wrong model if they're trying to enforce this passage in the way that is to submit your authority to them. And think of it like this.

You who are sitting in the pews, if you were to instead flatten this church and put it into a city and you go to Deacon's house, you go to neighbor's house, who's a congregational member, you're all responsible for the survival of that community.

And even, I won't get into this in this podcast, but there are even provisions for if somebody is suffering and poor, the community comes in to help them. Well, it's a lot different than a donation basket where you trust that the pastor is going to help the poor, and he has to intelligently decide, can I keep the lights on while giving money to all these poor people?

How much do I give? What percentage of my salary do I give them? None of that existed. It just totally did not exist. So the other thing that I'll say is, the words themselves, it's really worth looking it up in the interlinear version of the Bible, because when you think words like overseer, because of the way that we've been trained, we think, well, that's somebody who is a, the king of his domain, but that's not really, what this is, eventually it did evolve over time and Christianity into the word bishop, but that word is potentially misleading because the first century

text that we have, it doesn't show the monarchy of the monarchy of a bishop society, I guess if you call it this, as a more developed office until much, much later, when Hebrews was transmitted, none of that existed. I can already hear some of the pastors in the fivefold ministry starting to revolt and saying, John is trying to create anarchy. This is anti-biblical, he's got an anti-Christ spirit.

Well, I'm going to challenge them by Acts 20, and this is not me trying to be theological, this is just simply, I read the book, I know what is in the book, I know, I know what's in Hebrews, I know what's in Acts, I have read it, and I want to empower people who are submitting themselves falsely to the authority of these people that you can't, you can't biblically make that argument. In Acts 20, it says, he sent to Ephesus and called the elders plural of the church. He didn't say elder, he said elders. Those same men,

it says, the Holy Spirit has made you overseers. It goes on to say, if you continue reading, to shepherd the church. So are they shepherds in the fivefold ministry? Are they overseers? In the fivefold ministry? No, this is a community of people. So let's talk to another example, in Titus 1, Paul writing to Titus says, to Titus, mine own son, after the commoner faith, it says, for this cause I left you in Crete, and it goes on to say that I'm wanting to ordain elders in every city as I had had appointed thee, and he wanted to appoint other elders.

He goes on to say the qualifications of such an elder. And then in verse 7, it says, for if a bishop be blameless. And think about that. It's an elder and it's a bishop.

In many church settings, this is not really that big of a problem. A bishop is an elder, but if you think about the church hierarchy, this is a significant problem. Because in church hierarchy, the bishop was at the top and it went all the way down to the elders. Paul is not writing to Titus to create a church hierarchy. He's more to the point saying that I'm appointing leaders in the city, into the communities that the gospel is spreading, just like I did you. And there are various nuances to the translations, of course, you can go read through some of those nuances.

The church was largely in small communities that were in much larger communities of different pagan religions. And so they couldn't have the Christian temple like they do today with a big mega church and a pastor and the speaker and Stone Age band clicking the drums. It just simply would not have worked. There would have been a lot of conflict. And so the early Christians, as they were growing and spreading Christianity, it was a lot of meeting in the homes. It was a community, not a mega-church.

Have you ever wondered how the Pentecostal movement started, or how the progression of modern Pentecostalism, transition through the latter reign, charismatic and other fringe movements into the new apostolic reformation? You can learn this and more on William Brandham Historical Research's website, William-Branham.org. On the book's page of the website, you can find the compiled research of John Collins, Charles Paisley, Stephen Montgomery, John McKinnon, and others, with links to the paper, audio, and digital versions of each book.

You can also find resources and documentation on various people and topics related to those movements. If you want to contribute to the cause, you can support the podcast by clicking the contribute button at the top. And as always, be sure to like and subscribe to the audio or video version that you're listening to or watching. On behalf of William Brandham Historical Research, we want to thank you for your support. So now let's talk through the history of how it began a transition from the early church model into what we see today. And I know everybody's thinking,

I'm going to go back to William Brandham and say, Brandham did this in the laterane movement. Because I grew up with this, Brandham definitely clearly was teaching people to create an authoritarian model. However, we're going to go way, way back. Remember in Acts 20, Paul summoned the elders and said some men or overseers and their responsibility was shepherding to the church. Go forward about maybe a generation, early second century. And you start to see what is being shaped as the structure of the church. And there's one bishop that begins to stand out to the local community.

And that is Ignatius. And I've been actually asked by a few people to talk through Ignatius and his role in all of this. Ignatius was the bishop of Antioch. And usually when people talk about him, they're talking about the early church and the church as it's beginning to form its foundation.

Well, part of that foundation, not many people realize, is directly relevant to what we're talking about today. And this is what makes him so important to us. We're not jumping forward to medieval Catholicism, which is I'm certain where everybody thought I was going to head with this. I'm going to go way back to Ignatius because we're barely out of the New Testament period whenever you start to see things change. And we're going to bring in the Magnesians. You can go look this up and think Wikipedia even has an article on it. You can read where Ignatius writes a letter to the Magnesians to

their bishop. up Damas, I think is how you say it. He's apparently a relatively young man, and he tells the congregation not to disregard him because of his youth, but that's where things start to get extraordinary. In Magnesians 3, and you can pull this up, there's a website called NewAdvent.org, which I spent so many hours reading after I left the Brannum cult, I wanted to know how to the early church form, what is in the early church, and it's quite shocking when you get into it. It really, really is. Anyway, you can read down to chapter 6, there's

a section that's entitled Preserve Harmony, and he says, since therefore I have in the Persons before mentioned, the whole multitude of faith and love, I extort you to study all things with a divine harmony while your bishop presides in the place of God. Let me say that again, while your bishop presides in the place of God, and your presbyter is in the place of the assembly of the apostles, along with your deacons, who are most dear to me and interested with the ministry of Jesus Christ, who is with the Father before the beginning of time, and

the end was revealed, do all then imitating the same divine conduct, pay respect to one another, let no one look on his neighbor after the flesh, but continually love each other in Jesus Christ, and here's where it starts to get interesting, let nothing exist among you that may divide you be united with your bishop, and here's the phrase, those that preside over you as a type and an evidence of your immortality.

So let that sink in, and compare that to what we just talked about not ten minutes ago in Acts 20, Acts 20 laid it out like this, you have elders, some people who are overseers and their work is the work of a shepherd, in other words they're all doing similar work, and now Ignatius changes it a bit, and he says you have a bishop and you have a Presbytery and you have Deacons and people, and you don't necessarily need to look at it like he invented this, this is something that evolved over time, whatever happened between these two sources,

Acts and this book I'm reading here, by the time we reach Ignatius we start to see that there's a clear structure developing in the church, and it's developing outside of the book of Acts and some of the Bible that we have access to read. So the point I'm trying to make is whenever people look at some of the things like this, and you examine it theologically, you're looking backwards in time, and you're reading it through the theology of the current era, and Ignatius was reading it through the theology of his era, looking backwards in time.

obviously. Well, if you look at it from a historical standpoint, it's difficult to make that leap. How did it develop into what we see by Ignatius' time? So, it gets stronger. We can go to, I think it's pronounced trillions, Ignatius says, you are the subject to the bishop as to Jesus Christ.

The interesting part about this is, I grew up hearing that phrase, but take bishop out and put Branum in. You are subject to the prophet, is how we would say it, which meant Branum as to Jesus Christ. And it was just so damaging to the people because you had to have this mediator between God and man. And the Bible clearly says there is no mediator between God and man. But Ignatius, and this is part of the early church, before it even reaches the the councils of Rome that everybody points to as creating the church structure, he's already

got it. So, this is significant when you look at the timeline of this. In the epistle to the Samarnians, he goes so far as to say that wherever the bishop appears, let the multitude of people also follow him there or be there. And those of you who are watching the YouTube feed, you can see it in just simply the titles that they have given these sections of his letter, let nothing be done without the bishop. Be subject to the bishop, etc. These titles are, they weren't in the original manuscript as far as I understand it. It was just a letter, but they have categorized it based off

of his meaning, which is the bishop is in full control. So, he is essentially saying you have the bishop, you have the congregation, you have the Eurichrist, you have the baptism in church unity, and he is declaring that the bishop is the head or all of this. So, therefore, the bishop isn't simply the best preacher. He's basically the congregations administrator. So, you start to see this business church hierarchy being set up. I'm calling it business because of today's world, but in the world gone by, it was just basically an administration of the people, and he is becoming

the visible organizational leader of the group. We were actually told in Brannemism, and I've heard this in other groups as well, that the Council of Nicaea is where all of this began to change and take shape, and it was because of the Catholic Church. Catholic Church got its hands in it, it created this hierarchy, etc. But this was 200 years before the Council of Nicaea. We're talking two centuries before, and he's going just a bit outside of the text of the Bible that we have at least. So, you have a single bishop whose crowd must appear, I mean, think the Pope is the good example that

I would say in the Catholic Church today. When the Pope appears, all the crowd must come. Well, that's exactly what he's saying for the bishop. Now, it should probably pause, and for the theologians out there who are familiar with this history that I'm talking about, who know it much better than me and know the theology behind it, I should probably qualify what I've said in that it wasn't so much that he was trying to create an authoritarian Christianity by no means, and you can't even really say at this point in time, look how authoritarian Christianity had

become because it had not. Ignatius isn't writing a church management system, he's not developing the new apostolic reformation or lettering nonsense. He's basically writing church, I guess you could call it church management manuals in a very peaceful environment is what he's doing, but if you read his letters, they show real anxiety about divisions and wicked doctrines, and I think it's Philadelphia's, you can go look that up on the site, he says something to the effect flee from the divisions and the wicked doctrines. So he's dealing with a problem that is a human problem, and it's a real problem, and when you weigh this into the balance scales of church history,

it's a problem that it's almost impossible to solve. When you had the little communities like I talked about in the book of Acts, when you get some person in the community that has a hairbrain doctrine or notion, where everybody in the community might say, look man, that's not quite right, and explain why and try to correct it. And if one person gets to be a bad apple, where you just say, I'm sorry, you probably might find a different community because you're just a small group of people. But once you grow into a multitude of people, how do you do this? How do you control it?

Somebody gets an opinion on doctrine that's different from the rest of the group. Well, if they can get two or three people to join with them, now they've got a small crowd, and when you get a small crowd, people get curious, they come, join the crowd, it turns into, oh my gosh, now we've got a movement within the crowd. The movement says, we don't like those original guys, we want our own thing and they split. And I've just described every denomination in existence, every splinter group, every movement, brannemism, all of this stuff, it really comes

down to that. And he is trying to address that problem, which is a good thing. So it's not that he's a bad guy, he's bringing anything, but it is important because you can start to see how the church is progressing and why, and it's written right there in his letters, you can go look these letters up. So what Ignatius was trying to peacefully solve turned into a real problem when you continue, because as he's sending these letters, telling people they need to trust the bishop, they need to be accountable to the bishop, what happens when somebody rises up and says, why should

I trust your bishop? And that's essentially what happened, because by the time of the second century, you start to see nosticism coming into the picture. And Christians weren't just arguing about who is in charge at this point.

They were actually arguing about what Christianity was. The argument had changed from who should we trust to, well, what is this religion that we're in? And that's a big deal. Dynostics weren't really a rival denomination like a lot of people mistakenly think.

It is a group of people that began to develop from within, think of it like Laterane. To the assemblies of God, the Laterane were the nostics of their day. They were bringing in these heretical doctrines.

They were starting to do things that weren't good and were laying the groundwork for a lot of destructive cults, which we have seen did develop from all of this. Well, they tried to draw a line in the sand, we don't want you in our group, but they were part of them.

So how do you separate the people who were part of you at one point in time and then later became a different group? I spent many, many months, years probably studying the works of early Christian apologists who were talking about nosticism.

One of them was earnaices against heresies. He goes through and he documents all of these different groups that adopted some pagan idea, something that came out of one of the pagan religions, embedded it into their group and it was a mixture of Christianity and pagan doctrines.

And more to the point, they were adopting the themes from the mystery cults. And there's a real problem here because when you introduce the secret knowledge, now you've got this conflict in a way that Christians, they can't understand it if they don't have the knowledge.

What is the secret knowledge you're talking about? And those who are in the group say, well, they're the ones that don't have the knowledge. I cut myself off from them. We're the ones with the truth.

We hold the secret, they can't even understand the secret. That's really, essentially that's what happened with Brannemism as he began to splinter off of the latter-rain movement. Well, earnais, he goes through and he talks about this and says that these truths that were transmitted orally by the people that we read about in the book of Acts, suddenly they were merging with hidden mysteries and those who were receiving them were receiving divine knowledge.

So think the word of faith movement, think, latter-rain, think, Brannemism. I have a new revelation. I have new mana. That's what they were doing with Nosticism. And interestingly, he took it all the way back to Rome.

So for those of you who were influenced by Brannemism or know some of the history, Brannem labeled earnais as one of the church age messengers and said that earnais rose up to fight this evil doctrine that was coming that would eventually establish into the Roman Empire, the Roman Hierarchy, the Catholic Church, so on and so forth.

While he's railing against that, Brannem hadn't actually never read against heresies. Because if you read against Heresy's book three chapter three, he takes the line of succession of the apostles all the way back to Rome.

And for those of you who were looking at Nahr and saying, this apostolic succession thing, all of this is new apostolic reformation stuff. Well, this chapter predates Nahr quite a bit. We're talking all the way back to the second century.

And he says, essentially, that if you want to know where the truth actually comes from, you need to trace that truth through the succession of apostles all the way back. And there in the second paragraph, he says, all the way back to the universally choked church known and founded at Rome.

But he's saying specifically the universal church known and organized at Rome by the most glorious apostles, Peter and Paul. And let me read book three chapter three paragraph two, because this is where you start to see the church hierarchy take place.

He's talking about the church that's organized at Rome, and he says the universally church known church founded and organized at Rome by the two most glorious apostles, Peter and Paul, and also by pointing out the faith preached to men, which comes down to our time by the means of the successions of the bishops, the matter of necessity that every church should agree on this church.

Let me repeat that. Every church should agree with this church on account of its pre-eminent authority. So I know those of you listening are thinking, okay, well, John, the Protestant Reformation solved all of this stuff you're talking about.

That's exactly what we were taught in Branemism. We were taught that not here, NAS, but the Catholic church had created this rigid authority, and because of that authority, everybody was submitting to the Roman church.

And because of the Roman church submission, it developed into this thing that Martin Luther decided to break down. And if you're Protestant, that's what you are trained to believe. But think about what happened, because what we see in the New Apostolic Reformation today, what we see in all of these extremist groups that developed from it, is the same hierarchy.

And instead of going back to Rome as the central authority, they'll go back to the central authority of whatever is the denomination, whatever is the central figure, if it's a cult, or a group of men, if it's a semi-cultish control group, I'll say it like that, a high control, high demand group.

The Reformation breaks the chain, but it does not eliminate the authority. Because Martin Luther and the other reformers, as they're attacking the authority, there's suddenly this major shift, and that shift, Martin Luther called it Solus Scriptura by Scripture alone, Scripture over the ecclesiastical claims, priesthood of believers, basically.

And what he did essentially was he just simply reconfigured it. instead of the Catholic hierarchy, you've got ministers, you've got elders, you've got church discipline, you've got confessions, you've got congregational authority. You have essentially the same thing, but in a totally different model.

And the reason for this, it isn't that he was trying to create a structure that matched the Catholic church. He was doing the same thing that I mentioned earlier with Ignatius. We have a multitude of people.

We have potential divisions. How do you control this? We want to remain out of the Catholic church. How do I establish it in a way? We have to have a hierarchy. You have to have a governing system.

And so that's really what it is. Restorationism is basically, we're going back to the original church, but which original do you go to? Do you go to Ignatius? Do you go to what was being said by the early Christian apologists?

They were all proclaiming a hierarchy and structure, so Martin Luther, going back to that original, he had to do it, but it appears they didn't go back to just simply the Bible. So, Solar Scriptura, in that case, I would argue did they really go back to Solar Scriptura or did they go partially back to Solar Scriptura and then develop a hierarchy on top of it?

And theologians will battle me. I know that I don't look at this from a theological standpoint. I'm looking at it from a historical standpoint. So here's the part that all of you have been waiting for.

How is this William Brannum historical research? How can you talk about church history, John? You haven't even mentioned Brannum's name yet, other than in passing. Well, now fast forward through the Protestant movement into William Brannum, 1948, as the Laterane starts to break out, God's vindicated prophet.

And this is why I've taken you through this. What is it? Almost 2,000 years of history. And I'm trying to tell you and explain to you that Brannum was not the origin of this.

This is something that evolved over time through not even really mistakes, just by natural process of time. You start to see it developing into a hierarchy because it's getting so big. But what Brannum did is he tried to bring back a stronger church authority.

In Brannumism, he would be the Pope figure. And Jeffersonville, where I live, is the Vatican, which is funny if you think about that. But he's bringing prophetic authority. That's the big key here. He is redefining the offices.

While he is supporting the fivefold ministry, yes, the hierarchical version of fivefold, he's changing the offices in such a way where he's structuring it, where he can be at the top, even though he's a prophet.

And that's weird when you think of the New Apostolic Reformation. The Apostles are supposed to be the top guy. Brannum wanted to be the top guy, and he claimed to be a prophet. So he had this...

Weird unilateral. Yes, you're an apostle, but I'm a prophet. I'm actually above you because God's prophet is the one with the message for the day. That's what he would say. So in his weird hierarchy, apostles were just slightly either off to the side or sometimes below. Well, what he did was he established the notion that this divine lineage of doctrine that comes through the prophetic authority is the spoken word. In other words, we have the written word Martin Luther's solar scriptura. Well, my solar scriptura has Brannum is the words that come out of my mouth and convince

people of this. When you think about it, it just blows your mind. How do you convince people that your words, the thing that you say through a microphone, picture me sitting here before you holding this microphone saying, whatever I say into this thing, that is your ultimate authority.

Well, that's what he did. And he sparked a movement. Like I said, you draw two or three people out of the crowd, get them to listening. Well, suddenly you've got two or three people as a small crowd. People come, they're curious. They grow as it grows. Well, this grew into filled stadiums of 100,000 people would come listen to this guy claiming his microphone was the word of God.

And that's the precursor to the charismatic movement to the New Apostolic Reformation. They don't want to admit it, but that's really what's happening. He has redefined again what Martin Luther had redefined as far as it related to church structure and authority. Fast forward after Brannum's death comes the shepherding movement. Earn Baxter, who was one of the five founders of the shepherding movement, was Brannum's campaign manager. And as Brannum's campaign manager, it's very easy to see how he would share and be aligned with some of the doctrines. You have the succession, the same type of succession that I mentioned with Irenaeus. With that succession,

now you're building up to what becomes Nar because like Irenaeus would say, we trace through all of these lineage of people all the way back to the apostles. Therefore, follow the Roman church. Nar would say, we follow all of these people, these gods generals back in time. And Brannum's one of them, but they'll go back further obviously. So you have the same type of succession, you have the same type of structure. It is fully rebranded. And they're doing essentially the same thing. Why?

Because when you have a multitude of people, you have to have a way to govern it. But think about the transition from shepherding movement to the New Apostolic Reformation. You have this weird situation that's very similar to what Ignatius was dealing with. You have strange doctrines creeping in. And some of them, if you look at just the histories of some of the groups that spun off of the Laterane movement, some of them are going very, very destructive. And they're bringing in narcissistic ideas that bring them in.

in witchcraft, they're bringing in all of these different things that many of my peers are pointing out theologically, they're starting to do it in this movement, and these movements represent the networks that later get branded, the new apostolic reformation.

It's all of these apostolic networks. So think about this. All of these networks are establishing apostles and prophets and spiritual leaders. They're creating coverings, alignment, submission, honor culture. What is that? That goes back to our original conversation when we're talking about Hebrews, which you may have forgotten that that's what this podcast was about.

Hebrews 13.7, how do you control all of these people? How do you make them listen to the leader of each independent group? There is only one way. You tell them that the Bible says you must obey me as your leader, because if you don't, they're going to hop over to one of the other groups, or they might even go to the main stream group.

Some people who do all of the research that I've done may look at the things that Euronea is saying, and oh my gosh, he's saying go back to the Catholic church. Maybe I need to go back to the Catholic church.

If you follow all of that line of thought, you come up with this problem that you can't so often. What they did was they began to use Hebrews 13.17 as a weapon, and through Hebrews 13, now you can flip all of this up on its head.

You can add scriptures like, and I'm certain that you guys have heard this, touch not God's anointed. Do my prophets know harm? Every one of those verses that you hear that saying, essentially, trust your leadership and submit to your leadership's authority, is all wrapped up in that one verse, Hebrews 13.17, and they will give examples of the Bible of what happens to people who don't listen to the leader.

Chorus Rebellion, Miriam Challenging Moses, I can't tell you how many sermons I heard about that. David's refusal to kill Saul, they'll go to all of these Bible examples where they didn't submit to the authority and something bad happened.

But they don't tell you about the times in the Bible when they also didn't submit to the authority and something good happened. Read the book of kings. You see the leader rise up and fall into idolatry, and the people revolted, and something good happened.

They went back to God. It's a false narrative that they're trying to push, but they're weaponizing the verse from Hebrews. Hebrews 13.17 becomes the weapon to enforce all of this. But for those of you who saw the title or the preview and thought, John's going to take this back to Brannum as the origin of all of this problem, I'm showing you a historical pattern, and I want to leave you with this question.

Who speaks for God? This is really the problem. When you think of this history that I've put down before you, from Ignatius to Iernais, you can go all the way into the Reformation, you can go into Pentecostalism, Healing Revival and Beyond, the problem is there is a hierarchy of authority that has been established with each split as the group grows to a significant size.

Well, who's the one who gets to say, I'm the one who tells you what to do? Who's the one who's speaking on behalf of God? 2,000 years of Christian authority and we still have the same problem that we've had four years and years and years.

It's not one single, unbroken system. It is a huge, huge problem and the point I'm trying to make in all of this is not that you should not trust church authority by no means, but I'm saying that you should critically think about church authority because sometimes, as we've mentioned, sometimes you get a person who's wanting to create a division and they'll break off into error and that's what we see is 2,000 years of people breaking out into error.

People like Ignatius, they were really trying to do good and they were getting really frustrated that people were breaking off into error and you can follow that pattern all throughout time, people who go off into error.

The interesting part, which I'll leave you with the second thought to think through, the interesting part is this, when you consider the latter-rain movement, shepherding movement and beyond, what you see breaking out into these apostolic networks are people who went often to an error, a clear error and it was a well-defined error by the assemblies of God.

Well, people broke off of that error into other errors. Each one of these other errors, in many cases, formed what became the apostolic network. And C. Peter Wagner defined the new apostolic reformation, what he did and you can go back and read this.

This is his word's paraphrase, not mine. He says, I'm not naming something new. This is something that already exists and he's referring to all of these groups that broke out from the original error of latter-rain into different errors.

And yes, there were some good mixed in with the error, of course, but he's talking about errors as well. And that is the foundation, the peer foundation for the new apostolic reformation. So if you've enjoyed our show and you want more information, you can check us out on the web.

You can find us at William-Brandom.org. For more about the dark side of the new apostolic reformation, you can read Weaponize Religion from Christian Identity to the NAR, available on Amazon, Kindle, and Audible.